64. Anu Atluru - Chasing Something Heavy
Watch the video
Description
Anu Atluru (X, Substack, Website) is a writer, builder, investor, and doctor. On her Substack, Working Theorys, she has published 100 theories about people, technology, art, and the future. These days she writes, collaborates with founders and investors, and is working on a book. Anu is an observer: of people, of companies, and of why things are the way they are.
We start with Malcolm Gladwell’s “The Coolhunt” and the difference between cool, status, and prestige. We talk about why she calls her essays working theories instead of laws, inspiration from Orwell on writing, her many unpublished drafts, and her essay on making something heavy. We discuss products with great premises, social utilities, why skills drift toward art or sport, people who are differently free, using AI without mistaking activity for agency, insider media, and her great movie theory. We end on Before Sunrise, Survivor, and Jim Carrey.
I hope you are inspired to observe closely, make something with weight, and walk through the door when it opens.
Dialectic is presented by Notion. Notion is a collaborative workspace for your life's work and the place to keep the memory, context, skills, and documents you and your team use to work with AI. As you move between different agents and tools, Notion is the single shared hub where all of that context lives. Models and agents keep changing fast, and Notion stays the reliable place that holds your context through all of it. Learn more at notion.com/dialectic.
Timestamps
- (0:00) Intro: Anu Atluru
- (2:26) Start: Catching Cool
- (13:30) Being an Observer & Working Theorys
- (27:55) Orwell on Writing
- (40:54) Making Heavy Things
- (1:01:27) Why Media and Software
- (1:04:39) Good Premises & Social Utilities
- (1:18:07) Art & Sport
- (1:23:10) Differently Free
- (1:32:26) Writing with AI
- (1:39:32) Media and Machines
- (1:43:48) Insider Media
- (1:50:57) The Great Movie Theory
- (2:00:16) Great Conversation & Before Sunrise
- (2:08:58) Walk Through the Door
Links & References
-
Working Theorys (Anu’s Substack)
-
"The Coolhunt" (Malcolm Gladwell, The New Yorker, 1997)
-
Eugene Wei - Amusing Each Other to Death (Dialectic)
Show fewer references
-
"Why I Write” (George Orwell)
-
Writing Wrapped (50+ essays)
-
The Great Wave off Kanagawa (Katsushika Hokusai)
-
East of Eden (John Steinbeck)
-
“Writes and Write-Nots” (Paul Graham)
-
The Invention of Lying (2009)
-
Paul Scherer (Dialectic)
-
Anu's art-or-sport talk at Sana AI Summit
-
Henrik Karlsson (Dialectic)
-
Nicole Seah (Dialectic)
-
Luca Guadagnino's Artificial essay
-
Jasmine Sun (Dialectic)
-
Whiplash | There Will Be Blood | The Last Dance | The Cost of These Dreams
-
Bong Joon-ho quoting Martin Scorsese in his 2020 Oscars speech
-
Adam Mastroianni (Dialectic)
-
Nineteen Eighty-Four (George Orwell)
-
TBPN (Dialectic)
Transcript
YouTube adds the 1:37 Opening Highlights, so YouTube times are +1:37.
2:26 Start: Catching Cool
Jackson: (2:26) Anu Atluru. I'm not certain I got that right, but so nice to be with you.
Anu: (2:31) Nice to be with you.
Jackson: (2:32) Long time coming. I want to start with something you referenced a few places that I think is a favorite piece of yours, which is Malcolm Gladwell's The Coolhunt, I think from '97 or '99 in The New Yorker.
Anu: (2:41) Okay.
Jackson: (2:41) I read it. It's great. It's fun. It's very Malcolm, but it's also clearly before he's fully formed. He's talking about these people who are sort of, I guess what you would call trend reporters now, for Reebok and for shoes and so on.
I couldn't help as I read it—and maybe it was because it came from you—but I couldn't help thinking, "Oh, interesting. This is kind of what you do for your world," somewhat. Not with the same level of hype, but certainly this sort of trying to take stock and draw the boundaries.
You're also—maybe something that felt really resonant is—you're kind of calling your shots. I'm curious how, if at all—I mean, it sounds like maybe the comparison sort of resonates and sort of doesn't—how that piece influenced you.
Anu: (3:38) Well, one, I think it just feels very different than the very online world of trends that we're in now. So it's almost like a time capsule to the past of looking at how a trend was actually spotted, which I feel like we don't even get to see that anymore because the cycle of a trend is so fast.
If you talk about fashion, if you talk about anything, it's very hard to actually even trace the lineage of a trend. And I think what I liked about that piece is it was very much like these trend spotters: they're physically in a location where kids are going to be wearing stuff that isn't popular yet.
They're kind of following them around, trying to just observe and form their own opinions, but then also understand culturally where these shoes are cool or not cool or vice versa.
So I think, I guess one thing is just that it felt so different that it stuck out to me. But then at the same time, I think the principles in the piece feel very timeless and still very relevant.
I feel like you're putting me on the spot. I don't know if I remember all the "rules of cool," but there are three rules of cool, which he stitches together in the piece—which certainly is something I would appreciate because it kind of creates somewhat of a theory or a framework around this.
I'm just not in the right order, but one of them is certainly: you can only see cool if you know cool, or some version of that.
Jackson: (5:10) They're all recursive.
Anu: (5:11) Yeah, they are. So that one feels so timely to this whole taste conversation we have these days—who has taste or who doesn't have taste, or can you learn taste or can you not?
I don't think that piece is necessarily talking about taste so much, but the fact that you would say, "Oh, you only know cool if you are cool," I do think there actually is some truth to that. You can just replace the word "cool" or "taste" with something else, maybe that's a little bit narrower.
Then one of the other ones is certainly: as soon as you catch cool, it's gone, or some version of that.
Jackson: (5:45) Yes, yes.
Anu: (5:45) And that feels obviously so true. It's like as soon as something becomes trendy and everybody's talking about something and memeing something and it's predictable, it becomes passe almost immediately.
So I feel like those principles, despite it being such an offline time, to me felt like hyper-relevant for today. Which is why I pretty much recommend that piece to anybody that is in a creative business world or interested in that world, because it's very much timeless. But still, I guess now, almost 30 years ago.
Jackson: (6:21) And interestingly, it feels very of that time—like it's very "in time"—but the concept—
Anu: (6:26) Down to the names. Yeah, I think it's like Miss Baisy or something.
Jackson: (6:31) Baisy and Dee Dee are their names. You write a lot about status.
Anu: (6:36) I do.
Jackson: (6:37) How do you think about that kind of "cool" concept next to something like status? And in what ways are they similar? And what ways are they different?
Anu: (6:46) Well, one, I just think that status is kind of this little... it's one of the human drives that just kind of pervades everything, but maybe we don't necessarily like to talk about a lot because it doesn't always feel like... nobody wants to say they're extremely status-seeking, even though people want to be high status. So there's that little recursive kind of conflict there.
One of the things I do a lot and enjoy a lot is observing. Observing people, observing companies, observing why things are the way they are, why people are the way they are, why they say what they say and do what they do, and what they may be thinking that's different than what they're saying or doing.
Jackson: (7:31) By the way, this is why I think that piece felt so fitting. It’s two layers of this: these women who are amazing at going and observing the kids, and then it’s Malcolm trying to observe them observe.
Anu: (7:40) Yeah, yes. I think there are a few things that lend to that type of observation. One of them is something like status, because nobody wants to talk about it so much, but it’s very visible.
Jackson: (7:53) Yes.
Anu: (7:53) I think even things like the chase for fame, or the chase for money, or ambition in general are things that we don’t talk about so "on-face," but are very observable—particularly in the worlds that we’re in, in this kind of tech-media-adjacent world.
I’ve been in a lot of worlds with very ambitious people who are pursuing different things, and there’s a common thread across all those worlds that I see.
Jackson: (8:21) What’s interesting to me is that "cool" actually feels like a harder thing to talk about. Or maybe it’s not harder to talk about; maybe it’s more discussed, but it’s less legible.
Anu: (8:31) Okay. Yeah.
Jackson: (8:31) Whereas people like you or our friend Eugene Wei have sort of tried to deconstruct that. One of the things you talk about a ton that I want to talk more about later is: what status game are you playing?
One great way to aspire to a status is to deliberately opt out of another status game. And "cool" almost feels even more elusive; it’s actually closer to this taste thing. Maybe it’s not worth trying to litigate too explicitly, but...
Anu: (8:58) No, I think there’s a quality of "cool," which is if you are cool and a social group thinks you’re cool, that gives you status.
Jackson: (9:10) Yes.
Anu: (9:11) But trying to be cool makes you lose status.
Jackson: (9:16) Yes, in a way that trying to be high status doesn’t necessarily do. There are a lot of people very explicitly trying to be high status, and it works.
Anu: (9:23) Yeah. I think status is much closer to, to your point, slightly legible hierarchies inside the community that you’re in or inside the game that you’re playing.
I like to use this word "prestige." Maybe there are three adjacent things. There’s status, which is your position on some sort of hierarchy. Sometimes those are legible games that you can play, and often positional power can even give you status.
Prestige, I think, is an earned form of status, or it’s perceived to be earned in the sense that it’s an admirable form of status. You are really smart, you make something really high quality, or you consistently demonstrate what this group thinks is high taste.
All those things can give you status, but the point being, those are admirable forms of status. You’re happy to have them and aspire to them, versus just moving up a hierarchy. So, that’s one distinction I draw there.
Jackson: (10:27) What are the mechanics of prestige? If I were to take what you just said directly on the nose, you're saying that one of the issues with status and with "cool" is that if you try to get it, it slips out of your hands.
I think prestige is this form of very high status that everyone likes and appreciates. So it seems pretty obvious that you would just ruthlessly pursue prestige. Is there something preventing that from happening? Or is it about excellence, or...?
Anu: (10:54) Yeah, I think the way I said it before is it feels like a more meritocratic way to get status. Now, I think that word "meritocratic" has become a little convoluted as well, so I don’t always know if that’s the right way to explain it, but it feels more earned on the basis of something that you achieved.
Jackson: (11:15) Yep.
Anu: (11:17) So even, I mean, I think there’s "prestige media," which I have talked about, versus just media with high status or known figures as personalities. There’s prestige television, there’s prestige film, there’s prestige schools.
Jackson: (11:35) What’s the difference between prestige and highbrow?
Anu: (11:38) I think there’s a significant overlap.
Jackson: (11:39) Okay.
Anu: (11:40) But I think it’s because the people who care the most about prestige also care about being highbrow. Highbrow certainly has to do with quality and all of these things that we want it to have to do with, but I think it also has to do with some sort of slight avant-garde nature where it’s not mainstream, at least to me.
I think that lowbrow-to-highbrow curve certainly embeds in it a mainstreamness.
Jackson: (12:10) It’s like no one actually watches Succession. The amount of people who actually...
Anu: (12:13) Okay, good example, which I’m sure you and I both were interested in: the New York Times top 100 TV shows list that came out recently. Why is Succession so high on that list? There are so many prestige TV shows that are more recent that are on that list.
One, I think the type of people who read the New York Times and want to vote in these would be more likely to watch those things. And two, they’d be more likely to want to say that those are their favorite things as well.
Jackson: (12:42) That generalizes to so many things.
Anu: (12:45) Sure. I’m painting with a bit of a broad brush there.
Jackson: (12:48) But—
Anu: (12:48) I think that’s an example of where you're saying, "Okay, where does prestige overlap with highbrow?" You could say something like Succession has an earned prestige in the quality of the parable they're drawing and the making of the show. I think it’s a good show.
Jackson: (13:05) Yeah.
Anu: (13:06) I just think it’s not as good as people say. And maybe that gap is more about the fact that it fits a highbrow identity.
Jackson: (13:14) In the taste thing, it is tasteful to signal. People are trying to signal something about themselves with the selections, more so than the actual appreciation.
Anu: (13:25) It’s a good show. I don’t want the Succession heads to come after me.
13:30 Being an Observer & Working Theorys
Jackson: (13:29) Why are you—and I don’t know how true it’s been over the course of your life, I know you’ve written for a very long time, but at least in the last five years—why are you so drawn to being the observer, or maybe even the anthropologist?
Anu: (13:47) I kind of think that everything about a person or about things is somewhat nature and somewhat nurture.
Jackson: (13:53) Okay.
Anu: (13:55) So I’m sure there's an element of me that’s just a curious person. I do a fair bit of self-analysis as well, so I don’t think it’s just that I’m observing other people.
There is a bit of this analytical—you can call it overthinking, anthropological, or meta-thinking—nature to it. It’s probably all four.
I think that probably is naturally a personality trait, but you can learn so much by observing. Sometimes I think that what I learn from observing is not put to its maximal use, but it’s put to use in a way that I like and enjoy.
A lot of these observations could even be much more instrumental in a political context, a business context, or some sort of other "I’m trying to get something" context.
Whereas I think I’m very happy to take a lot of those observations, abstract up a level, and see what the patterns and commonalities are. Is there a thread or some sort of Working Theorys that combines these things, and how does that explain the world?
I’m very satisfied if I feel that it does explain something that is resonant to other people.
Jackson: (15:20) A framework or a pattern or whatever. Right.
Anu: (15:22) Yeah. And that has consequence, of course, but there's an extent to which me just saying the thing also loses some of the power of me being able to use the thing to—
Jackson: (15:32) Exploit it.
Anu: (15:33) —in some context.
Jackson: (15:34) Yes.
Anu: (15:34) So I have thought that at various points in time. But I think the best high for me is in figuring the thing out and then putting it out in the world and seeing what other interesting people think this resonates with, and what scenarios it fits.
Maybe I'm meeting people who I respect who have similar lines of thinking and thinking about it at the abstract and higher level, versus being like, "Okay, I'm gonna go use this as my competitive advantage."
Jackson: (16:05) Yeah, don't tell anybody about it. Go keep this.
Anu: (16:07) Yeah.
Jackson: (16:09) Well, let's talk about it. So, a couple things. Number one, you've written and talked a lot about this kind of hybrid model, or this reflexive or symbiotic model of writing and building together—which, at least on the surface, sounds like you're maybe not giving yourself quite enough credit about the building half of that.
And then on the other hand, the name of your blog is Working Theorys. I think if people know you for anything, it's probably one of your theories or it's this idea. How do those two things fit together? And why not just be the writer? Why not just be the theorist? There are plenty of those people.
Anu: (16:48) Well, one, upon reflection, the writing thing has been there since a very long time. I didn't necessarily know it. When you're younger, you do things, but you don't necessarily realize this is going to be the big common thread in your life.
So I think somewhat in retrospect, I realize that. I have been writing in some form or fashion since school, and in every career path I have had along the way, I've taken up a different form of writing.
Jackson: (17:14) How much of that writing has had an external component?
Anu: (17:17) A lot, historically.
Jackson: (17:18) Okay. So you've been writing for other people, publicly, online, whatever it might be.
Anu: (17:22) Yeah. And privately. But I think publicly much more so, which is part of that function of writing at any given point in time.
Let's say I'm—let's use the word builder loosely, which I think can be used loosely. You can be a writer-founder, you can be a writer-designer, you can be a writer-director, you can be a writer-fashion designer. I think these combinations actually all exist.
So whatever the builder thing is, I think the writing is actually a very useful reflective component. It's useful for planning, it's useful for understanding what you're thinking. It's useful for abstracting up one layer above what you get to execute.
People who build products only get to execute one version of that product. But before they decide that, they're thinking about many versions of a product and maybe having a lot of understanding through that process about what makes a good product, for example.
Jackson: (18:30) Well, some people do it that way. I think a lot of people actually just pull a thread. There's very little upfront thinking.
Anu: (18:37) Fair. That's reasonable.
Jackson: (18:39) I only say it to distinguish—you are clearly someone who is operating, at least from what I can tell, largely from this "I'm gonna understand the world, have a theoretical worldview, have a point of view, and then sort of attack or build out of that."
Anu: (18:53) Yeah, I think that's true. I don't flatter myself; I'm not the only writer-builder. I feel like I know many others, so maybe that's why I think that. But yes, it's certainly true that I don't think everybody feels either called to or maybe as deeply meditative on the universe around the thing that they are doing.
Jackson: (19:10) Do the things you make and build always or almost always come out of your writing?
Anu: (19:18) Not always. There's this loop. I think sometimes in the past—we'll get to the balance, because I wrote in Writer Builders that there are phases where people are mostly building and there's phases where people are mostly writing.
I think I'm in a mostly writing phase right now. But sometimes there's an idea in the past that I wanted to build, and through building that I've come up with a working theory. Other times I'm like, "Oh, here's a working theory based on observations of people," and maybe that gives me an idea for a social product or a product I want to build.
So it does happen both directions. But if you're spending time mostly writing, then you're doing mostly observing as the input versus building something being the input. So there's probably some complex web to weave here. I think it goes both directions.
Jackson: (20:12) It's interesting you made a comment about the word building being sort of wide. You could also use the word making, although I think there probably is a distinction between those two things.
It's interesting that all those other things you listed are creative acts, basically, that you kind of lumped into building: filmmaking and fashion. Writing is also a creative act, and you're not putting it in the building bucket. You're separating it out.
Anu: (20:41) I think it's a craft. I think there's some subtle distinction I make from building, even though I do think it's a craft and you are creating something. But I think when I pair writing and building, the writing is serving a function for the building that is slightly different than when it's writing alone.
Jackson: (21:01) Okay. So if you were writing a book, that feels like more of the mode of building.
Anu: (21:06) Correct. Or if you're writing an essay unto itself, there is an aim unto itself. So you are creating something.
Jackson: (21:12) Whereas you're using writing instrumentally for all these other goals.
Anu: (21:16) Somewhat. Like Daniel Roseberry—he's the creative director of Schiaparelli, the fashion house. He talks about how he had a pen earlier than he could talk. His process is still that he has to sketch first before he sends anything to the atelier or he creates anything.
That's his medium or mode of thinking or reflecting or coming up with something. In that example, I think his sketching is writing and his building is making the actual designs and seeing that vision come to life to some extent.
That's an example where I can replace the words writing and building with sketching and producing a garment. I think that still holds, but they're symbiotic in some sense there. Whereas maybe somebody else is just a sketch artist unto themselves, and that itself is the creation. I think there's a different way you approach that thing and a different purpose for that thing.
Jackson: (22:18) It's funny; the word "theory" feels very fitting for the description you just gave.
Anu: (22:23) Probably. Yeah.
Jackson: (22:25) What have you learned about writing? I think the most recent one, at least on the blog publicly, is number 100. You've written 100-plus theories publicly. What has writing in that sort of construct done to your writing?
I also don't know if that was there from the very beginning, or to what extent it’s felt constraining or not, but what has that frame or hat done to your writing?
Anu: (22:51) Well, as far as Working Theorys, I think I've had that frame since the very beginning, at least of Substack. I certainly was writing a lot before that as well, but publishing more so with traditional publications and journals, because Substack obviously made that much easier.
So I think I just had it at the time already: I have all these ideas, but I don't want to commit to these being mathematical proofs. I don't really feel the need for them to be—
Jackson: (23:22) Anu's laws.
Anu: (23:23) Yeah, yeah. And actually, the theorist—the father of modern media, Marshall McLuhan, who’s very easy for me to cite many, many times—used to talk about his ideas more as probes, as opposed to laws of physics.
It's like you can put out a probe that generates a conversation that can actually exist in context and then learn, as opposed to, "Okay, I'm proving this incontrovertible idea that now forever is cemented in stone."
So I think I identify with that. In one way, it actually lowers the barrier for me to write. And then, has it become constraining? I think the way it becomes constraining sometimes is if I want to write something that I don't think has a theory.
Jackson: (24:17) Can you give me an example?
Anu: (24:19) Like a personal reflection, as an example.
Jackson: (24:23) You just need a separate blog, just called "Anu's Thoughts."
Anu: (24:26) Yeah. Or there's certainly times where I feel like some of the set of theories I've written are really strong.
Jackson: (24:35) This is a catalog. The bar is pretty high.
Anu: (24:39) Right. And then I might feel like—even though I call this a working theory—is this actually just a meditation or a musing, or something lower than the level of a working theory?
Jackson: (24:51) Do they have a similar shape in terms of the time to develop and how much rigor there is? Do some take five minutes and some take five months?
Anu: (24:59) It's very chaos.
Jackson: (25:01) How do you know it's ready to publish, or how do you know it's even ready to really write out?
Anu: (25:05) This is such a writer's—
Jackson: (25:09) Got to give the people what they want.
Anu: (25:10) Writer's chaos. Yeah. Sometimes, there's a handful that I can remember where I had the idea the night before, and then I woke up and just free-wrote it in two hours. It was already inherently structured enough.
Jackson: (25:26) Are those differentially better, worse, or is it not clear?
Anu: (25:31) I'm not sure about the performance—let me separate the performance. But I think I tend to feel stronger about those even far later, regardless of the performance, because I think there's a clarity of a thought that I had.
Also simply the fact that I was even willing to publish it that quickly suggests that I felt strongly enough about that as a holistic unit that was saying something.
Jackson: (25:55) And maybe it was percolating for nine months.
Anu: (25:57) It certainly was. It certainly was. But the lightning struck. I am one of those people that gets the benefit of a night's sleep.
I used to solve calculus problems in the middle of the night—not very complex problems, but there are other mathematicians that have talked about it. You go to bed with a really complex problem, and then in the morning you have the solution.
That happens to me sometimes with writing as well, because I guess I'm trying to work out an idea and then it's worked out. So it's great when that happens.
Other times, it's like there are a thousand observations in my head that I have collected, and I know they all go together, but getting it to a simple articulation of a theory is the hard part, and then that takes time.
It's not that I don't think it's there. It's that I'm thinking a bit about the audience: What do I need to do to make this easy to understand? Because I can't be explaining the thousand thoughts in my head, even if it seems simple to me.
Jackson: (27:02) And there's an atomic unit of them that needs to be moderately simple.
Anu: (27:06) I think so. This is where I think about things like, well, maybe if there's one that's really complex, I want to write a book about it. Or maybe if there's one that's really complex, it's only for a small audience of people, not for the mainstream—which I do feel for a lot of the things I write.
I kind of know before I publish something if that's going to be a mainstream piece or if it's going to be a niche piece. And I also kind of know if I think people are going to share it a lot or if I'm going to get DMs about it, which tend to be two different things.
Jackson: (27:38) Oh, they're separate things.
Anu: (27:40) Obviously people send you DMs if they like it as well. But there are certain portions of pieces—when I talk about what I say are a little bit like "elephant-in-the-roomy" topics—where I get a lot more DMs than people publicly sharing.
Jackson: (27:53) That's funny.
27:55 Orwell on Writing
Jackson: (27:55) You shared—I should reference it because it's my second reference from it—"Words that Matter." You did this list of recommendations and there were a bunch of amazing ones.
Probably the highlight, though, was Orwell on writing, and there were a few excerpts I wanted to talk to you about. First: "I do not think one can assess a writer's motives without knowing something of his early development."
Anu: (28:16) Okay.
Jackson: (28:16) You mentioned the nature-nurture thing. You mentioned this has always been around. Do you think there's something about you as a child, writing as a child, or maybe even the observer thing that came really early?
Anu: (28:34) Yes, it's definitely yes. Now I'm trying to figure out what the specifics are. One, I'm the youngest child in my family, so I think there's just a certain natural way you end up just trying to observe how everybody else is doing things, because you don't have the freedom yet to be doing a lot of those things.
And you have more time, actually, as people are out doing things. So there's a whole observational nature there. I think my parents are immigrants and they moved to... I grew up in Texas. Growing up, I think things are much more diverse now, but it wasn't quite as diverse of an area.
So I think to some extent, my parents were observing certain elements as well, and as a proxy, I was learning about these observations and making some of those observations myself, too.
I think there just is also a nurture part. It's almost like if you think people have gifts or something, they may also have curses to the things they're just really attuned to—patterns, ideas, thoughts, people's emotions. If you care at all about personality tests or astrology, then you might believe that there's some proclivity for something.
Jackson: (30:02) Yeah, sometimes people maybe don't let themselves develop those things. But it's funny you mentioned that. I was talking to somebody recently about how they were the youngest sibling and they had a bunch of older brothers or something.
It was like, violently—not physically violent, but lots of debate and all these things. And they were like, "I would go to my room and I would write out my thoughts."
Anu: (30:22) Wow.
Jackson: (30:23) They were all so fast. I needed the time to go be, as the youngest child.
Anu: (30:27) Yeah, I think there's another interesting thing. In my house, I'm the person who will always find the thing that's lost. Physically. No matter who lost it and what it is.
And there actually is embedded an observational thing in there as well, which is that usually, if I'm moving around the world, it's almost like I'm taking snap images of everything I see or hear or observe.
I'm able to recall those things later, even if at the time I didn't know that was a significant thing. So it's kind of always been there to some extent.
Jackson: (31:07) Another quote from Orwell: "I could not do the work of writing a book, or even a long magazine article, if it were not also an aesthetic experience."
How does that fit into—obviously, it could be prose, it could be something else—but how does that fit in, maybe especially given that the theory thing is very conceptual?
Anu: (31:30) Yeah.
Jackson: (31:30) Maybe it's in this writing, it's other writing, but how does that fit in?
Anu: (31:33) It's chock full of aesthetic. I think Orwell, in his "Why I Write" piece, says there's like four reasons why writers write, usually.
Jackson: (31:45) Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Anu: (31:46) And the first one is sheer egoism, if I remember correctly. The second one is aesthetic enthusiasm or aesthetic pleasure—I'm not sure which one it was.
Jackson: (31:56) How the words sit next to each other.
Anu: (31:57) Right. And then I think it's historical impulse and political aims or something. I think those are the four.
I remember really liking his articulation of the aesthetic impulse because I don't think people, as you point out, think of writing to be very aesthetic, unless it's flowery prose, perhaps.
Jackson: (32:16) Or poetry.
Anu: (32:17) Or poetry. There's such an elegance to a sentence or a word, or even like this "as soon as you catch cool, cool leaves." To me, there's such an elegance to the recursiveness or the paradoxicalness.
Jackson: (32:33) Yeah.
Anu: (32:34) I actually find a lot of elegance in single sentences, which is maybe also why I like Twitter and one-liners and aphorisms to some extent.
I think that is aesthetic. We usually think of it as a complex visual thing, but I think there's almost like a spoken or intellectual aesthetic to a simple and slightly surprising sentence, or theory, or whatever unit you would be looking at.
Jackson: (33:09) There's even a different aesthetic to a sentence read and a sentence heard. Right.
Anu: (33:14) I think the reason it feels so true is because there is an emotional feeling you get when you unlock a very aesthetic sentence or idea or paragraph. At least to me.
Jackson: (33:31) I agree. And there's plenty of good writing that's easy to understand. It's well written, it's expertly communicative, but it's not aesthetic.
And there's also writing that is—it's not even necessarily about what it's communicating, but it's the feel. As you say, it's about the feeling.
Anu: (33:49) I do think one thing that's interesting about Working Theorys, though, is that on the face, the prose seems not as important as narrative writing.
I feel like Venkatesh Rao has talked about this a lot. I don't know if you read Ribbonfarm, his old popular blog, but I think his articulation is writers versus thinkers and fiction versus nonfiction.
In that articulation, writers are the prose-focused folks and the thinkers are the idea-focused folks.
Jackson: (34:20) I see. Okay, this makes a ton of sense.
Anu: (34:23) And then there's fiction and nonfiction.
Jackson: (34:24) You're rubbing against that a little bit.
Anu: (34:26) Yeah. I'm saying that, on balance, I'm probably slightly more of a thinking writer than a writing thinker.
At least recently—although I am writing some fiction, more of the stuff people know I've written is nonfiction. So I think there are archetypes of what people expect for aestheticism or meaning or beauty or sophistication based on where you fall in that two-by-two, I suppose. Which I also love two-by-twos.
Jackson: (35:01) I saw a great two-by-two. It was a cocktail menu.
Anu: (35:03) Yeah.
Jackson: (35:04) It was like bittersweet. It was great.
Anu: (35:05) I reshared that one. I was like, "The two-by-twos have escaped nerd containment and I am extremely pleased," or something.
Jackson: (35:13) A couple more for Orwell: "I find that by the time you have perfected any style of writing, you have always outgrown it."
Anu: (35:21) I like it aesthetically so much that I want to say it's pretty true, because just that statement alone feels very elegant. I think it's partially true, for sure.
There's always this thing where if you go back and read old work, you're like, "It's not as good as I would like it to be if I were writing it today." I don't know if that's so much the style versus the articulation.
I don't feel that I've outgrown, for example, this idea of the Working Theorys being interesting to me. It's still infinitely interesting to me, actually.
Jackson: (36:00) Do you think the last 25 have been better than the first 25?
Anu: (36:03) Yes. There's been a whole evolution. I even deliberately played around with what is the cadence that I want to write.
There was one year where I published 50 essays because I was like, "Okay, I'm going to do one a week and see how this feels." I had a set of reflections after that.
And then there's others where I'm like, "Okay, I'm only going to write when I feel compelled and I have something to say." And then there's something in between.
So I think those do naturally produce different sets of things. I would say mostly, yes, you outgrow it to some extent, but I never outgrow finding a really compelling idea.
Jackson: (36:46) You put it like that.
Anu: (36:47) That's hard to outgrow, I suppose.
Jackson: (36:49) I agree. Maybe I just really like ideas.
But one last quote from Orwell: "And yet it is also true that one can write nothing readable unless one constantly struggles to efface one's own personality. Good prose is like a windowpane."
Are you effacing your own personality? How is that going? Or, to put it a different way, in what ways does self come through over the course of so much conceptual writing?
Anu: (37:28) The thing I learned that’s most obvious is what I’m consistently drawn back to. That tells me something about my personality, for sure—maybe just my interests, which certainly are a part of personality.
I think things I have not learned about myself but have been reinforced are traits, for example, even just in the process of writing. I certainly have perfectionistic tendencies, as I always have, and I think even the Working Theorys idea is probably to lower that barrier a bit.
But even still, I joke—but it’s actually true, and maybe these aren’t all fully formed—but I have hundreds of drafts just in my Substack.
Jackson: (38:12) And are they hundreds of variations, or are they all different?
Anu: (38:15) I’m sure there’s some halfway there, but there’s at least probably twice as many ideas compared to what I’ve published.
Jackson: (38:25) There’s probably a couple of viral essays in there.
Anu: (38:27) I’m sure there has to be. Unless I’m a really good filter, in which case that would be a little unfortunate. I think that’s a part of your personality.
If you’re shipping anything—I’m sure even with making this podcast—it’s like: make it exist, and then you can make it good. But you kind of want to make it really good.
Jackson: (38:45) You do want to make it really good. I have one episode I haven’t released yet, but it wasn’t because it wasn’t good. Although I know a lot of podcasters don’t release a lot of them. It depends a little.
Anu: (38:55) I think it’s a little different because you are asking somebody else...
Jackson: (39:00) Yes.
Anu: (39:01) ...to...
Jackson: (39:03) ...commit...
Anu: (39:03) ...to doing this thing.
Jackson: (39:05) You’re really afraid to be like, "I’m sorry."
Anu: (39:09) If anything, I feel like maybe a guest sometime would be like, "Hey, I don’t know if this was so great."
Jackson: (39:13) Yeah, that’s happened. But they’re wrong. They’re more likely to think it’s bad when it’s good than the inverse.
Anu: (39:20) That’s the blessing and the curse of being a writer: you get to choose when to put the work out. That sometimes is bad because you don’t put work out that you should.
Jackson: (39:29) Does anybody read it before it goes out?
Anu: (39:31) Very rarely. In the past, I used to have friends or people that I felt were particularly attuned to that topic read it. But I have found, one, I don’t know if I end up taking a lot of those opinions.
Two, it feels like an ask to make for something where I may not be taking the opinions that much. And three, I like to just push the button when I want to push the button—i.e., the publish button.
Jackson: (40:03) I mean more that you could give somebody access to the archive or the unpublished drafts and be like, "Are there any gems in here?"
Anu: (40:09) Oh, you mean those. I’m sorry, I thought you meant the drafts before I publish.
Jackson: (40:11) Yeah, either way. Like you’ve decided you’re already going to publish it if somebody’s going to even get to look at it.
Anu: (40:20) I think I might do something with those drafts at some point.
Jackson: (40:24) Oh, cool. Okay. They’re not dead; they’re just planted seeds.
Anu: (40:27) I’m sure there are a few whose time has expired because it might have been a timely idea. But I think I will probably do something with those drafts separately.
There is writing that I’ve written that I’ve chosen not to publish because I actually think it’s really good.
Jackson: (40:44) Why?
Anu: (40:45) It feels like...
Jackson: (40:47) You’re saving it?
Anu: (40:48) Kind of, a little bit. It feels like it merits something more than a Working Theory.
40:54 Making Heavy Things
Jackson: (40:54) Okay. Speaking of, you have an amazing blog post—I would say one of the best you’ve written, not just because of the idea, but particularly because of the way you communicate it—which is this concept of heavy and light work.
People should go read it, but a few lines stand out: "Light achievements beget light rewards. Deep down, you know light things don’t count." You use the phrase "momentum without weight." You talk about heavy things being not necessarily big, but dense and durable.
It’s a concept that is very intuitive in the physical world and is less intuitive, but as applicable—excuse me, applicable—in the digital world around the weight of things.
We’ve been talking primarily about the writing you do on Substack, which I think would fit into a category you described in the piece as "mid-weight." It’s not a tweet, it’s not this totally ephemeral thing, but it also isn’t extremely heavy. I would describe something like a podcast episode as similar. Maybe Working Theorys, the project, has more weight.
How has Substack and that kind of structure and cadence affected your work? And then how are you thinking about lighter or heavier things on the ends?
Anu: (42:14) Well, one, I’m also on Twitter, as you know, and so I feel like that’s certainly on the lighter end of the spectrum. There’s definitely a common thread that I like text-based mediums and platforms: Twitter, Substack.
In this arena, publicly sharing on Twitter fulfills a good amount of just that real lightness.
Jackson: (42:40) What do you do it for? The really light things.
Anu: (42:42) Well, one, I just have a lot of thoughts. Theories sometimes, but half-baked theories or ones that I don’t think merit an essay. If an essay could have been a tweet, then I will actually put it out as a tweet.
I think it’s fun to just get feedback from people on if those ideas resonate and how they resonate. I’ve made a lot of friends—I don’t even want to say professional, but people who share interests of mine—through Twitter, and I've taken those relationships from online to offline. I think there’s a lot of value there.
Jackson: (43:21) There’s two different things in what you just described. One is more about testing, and the second is more about bat signaling. Maybe the same thing can do both of those jobs.
Anu: (43:35) Yeah, I don’t do a lot of planning or thinking about what’s on my Twitter. I think my tweets serve many functions. One is to test an idea, but that idea also serves as a bat signal to people who might care about it.
Twitter is also just a phenomenal place to observe.
Jackson: (44:01) Do you think it’s a good place to observe?
Anu: (44:03) It has its vices, for sure, but I think it is a great place to observe.
Jackson: (44:06) Do you think you’re observing something real on Twitter?
Anu: (44:09) I think I’m observing layers of reality that are, in some cases, more extreme and, in other cases, more watered down.
I believe that a lot of my observation of Twitter tries to bake in whether I think it is extreme, whether it’s watered down, or whether it’s reality versus just the meta—the version of a person or idea that people are trying to put out there.
I’m humble enough to accept that I’m sure I’m being affected regardless, but as far as the analytical aspects go, I do feel like I spend a good amount of time trying to assess that for myself versus just taking it in.
Substack, I think what you said is pretty accurate. It’s a great place to do a somewhat regular essay or article. I do think Substack has gotten lighter, unfortunately. I love Substack, but as any network matures—particularly one that started out to be a home for serious writing with the premise being you can get paid to write—it instantiates a certain seriousness.
There have been these criticisms along the way that it’s just diary entries and listicles and viral bait now, or it’s just for growth marketers to build up listservs. I think that environment does make it feel less heavy.
Jackson: (46:01) Has it felt that way for your work?
Anu: (46:06) Yeah, I guess. Two distinctions there. It doesn't make me think that the stuff I'm writing is less heavy, but it does make me think that the participation in this ecosystem is less meaningful.
Jackson: (46:18) Got it.
Anu: (46:20) I view the participation there similarly to a participation in Twitter or somewhere else, even if the artifact that I'm introducing feels somewhat significant.
Which brings me to the third point, which is I am going to be writing a book and I'm working on that. That to me feels like a heavier, more enduring, kind of platform-agnostic creation.
Jackson: (46:49) You've slowed or stopped a lot of the essay or the theory writing, or at least are on a bit of a pause, it would seem. Is that directly a function of the book? How do these two things work together?
Anu: (47:03) I'm sure it is to some extent, but there's a lot of things. There are periods of time where I actually took three months off of just being online earlier in the year, or right at the turn of the year. I wasn't publishing then either.
That was one reason—I just decided to unplug and reset. Usually, I'm resetting spice tolerance. That's how I think about it.
Jackson: (47:32) Spice tolerance?
Anu: (47:33) Yeah.
Jackson: (47:34) I don't know about resetting spice tolerance.
Anu: (47:35) I'm one of these people that puts hot sauce on everything and it escalates to the point where it becomes not particularly healthy. So then I need to detox and restart.
Jackson: (47:48) For how long on the spice?
Anu: (47:51) I don't know. It's just like going back to bland foods, really.
Jackson: (47:56) Like for a month, for a week?
Anu: (47:58) Yeah, maybe a couple of weeks or something. The thing is, it's not painful to detox. It's just boring. The food tastes not good.
Jackson: (48:05) Do you do this with coffee or anything else, or just spice?
Anu: (48:07) No, just spice.
Jackson: (48:08) I love spice. We've got to get you on Hot Ones. What are you doing here?
Anu: (48:12) We can do a Hot Ones episode.
Jackson: (48:13) Yeah, part two. And how was the digital version of that detox?
Anu: (48:19) It was great. I think that my relationship to that is a little bit like—I can also appreciate the meta of me doing this. I'm thinking about the difference between the two things as I'm doing it.
I didn't go full off. I was lurking, but I wasn't posting. I find that posting is the actual addictive part of social media for me. Consuming is not the addictive part of social media for me.
Jackson: (48:46) Lucky you. That's certainly optimal for so many reasons. Not to say that posting is inherently healthy, but certainly optimal.
It's funny, you have this line in the piece about whether you could go a month or a year or a decade offline, both for the Working Theorys project and for this upcoming book. How do you measure that by your own standards?
It's a feel thing, presumably, at least until you do it. So I guess one of those is more like looking retrospectively, not to say the project's finished. And the other would be, as you think about the book, I imagine a huge part of it is wanting to make this substantial.
Anu: (49:31) In one way, I'm not too worried about whether I think it's going to fulfill that feeling, because I kind of feel like I can decide when I feel it is.
Jackson: (49:43) You can decide to be done, you mean?
Anu: (49:45) Yeah. Even with a lot of my essays, there are many essays where I know when I finish them, "This is really good to my standard." And I don't even really care if other people don't end up liking it. I'll still feel great about it.
There are other essays where the minute I hit publish, I'm like, "This wasn't good by my standard." But there's something about that publish button that instantly tells you.
I'm also the person that wants to finish something. The desire to finish something can get in the way of your own standard or your own belief in the completed thing. Once you're done with the finishing aspect, it becomes much more clear sometimes.
But with the book, I feel that it's such a long process from finishing it to publishing it and putting it out there that there's no publish button for me to push, really. So I'm not going to be done with it until I think it's good.
If I think it's good, then I'm going to be happy with it, kind of irrespective of—of course, I want it to do well and I want it to sell a lot of copies and have some enduring value—but I think I will know by the time it's done if it's a heavy thing for me.
Jackson: (50:59) Do you think Working Theorys will finish at some point?
Anu: (51:05) Probably all things finish, but not in concept, because I will always be thinking in that way.
Jackson: (51:13) Back to the idea comment, right?
Anu: (51:14) Yeah, but maybe in form factor.
Jackson: (51:17) Speaking for myself, I have no idea what it would look like to finish this project. If anything, I don't really have that much of a vision for it. The thing I like about it is that it's like a container to move forward, more so than some kind of destination or journey.
Anu: (51:34) I feel like for people who want to keep creating things, you need a next thing to create, or something you're feeling drawn towards to make you feel like maybe this chapter is closing.
Jackson: (51:47) That makes sense to me.
Anu: (51:49) We talk about these shows like Chicken Shop Date with Amelia Dimoldenberg. She's just wrapping up that show she's been doing for 10 years. I think she's airing the last episodes, like the interview she did with Drake.
Now she's got a rom-com that she's working on. She's done that for 10 years and she's like, "It's kind of time for this format to be ending."
I think that format is also requiring her to put on a persona that isn't exactly her. And I think that also dictates the whole show.
Jackson: (52:29) It more than a bit, it is sort of a bit.
Anu: (52:32) Right. And so I'm saying, when that's the case, you feel more like, "I can't do this show forever because this isn't me." At least that's my analysis.
It's like a lot of people who feel like they're typecast in sitcoms that could run on for a long time, and then they're like, "This is not me. I can't keep doing this for more than six years."
Jackson: (52:56) Do you think you've made anything heavy yet?
Anu: (53:01) That's the question. Do you—okay, here's my question. Do you think I've thought about that?
Jackson: (53:05) Of course. Of course.
Anu: (53:12) I think heavy-ish, but not heavy enough sometimes. The way I think about it is: if you could just say, "Here's one thing that represents me," and nothing else could represent you, would you be satisfied with that thing representing you?
Jackson: (53:30) No.
Anu: (53:31) But I'm saying there's even maybe within "heavy," there's spectrums. But on that definition, I don't think I have that thing yet.
Jackson: (53:43) Things you're proud of? This goes to the encore point, what you've written about, which I really like.
Anu: (53:47) I've made some products that I'm really proud of, but I don't know that I want that to be my one thing.
Jackson: (53:52) Yes. But the thing I'm referencing is you made some comments somewhere about talking about doing an encore. In any way, for a certain kind of person, it’s sort of like admitting that you have made something you're actually really proud of, or that was good.
Anu: (54:05) Yeah, hard to do.
Jackson: (54:07) So this last bit also connects to the idea of: is the bar high enough? There's some other old tweet where you say the only way to be happy with your work is to raise your skills to the level of your taste.
I can't help but think that both in that concept and in what we were talking about, there is this element of a Red Queen's race or something. Like by the time your skill matches your taste, your taste will have kept moving.
I think it's just like when you write the book—do you think it will be about, not to say you won't be proud, of course, but it will be like, "Well, what's heavier than a book?"
Anu: (54:39) A second book that feels not heavier. But to the point around maybe your appreciation for things that you have finished goes down because your taste changes or just time passes, then it's like, what's the next quest? I think I'll always have a next quest.
Jackson: (54:56) But you don't think it inherently must always get bigger? Like for Elon, it must always get bigger in all senses of whatever.
Anu: (55:03) Yeah, I don't think so. I think for me bigger is less about scale and more about some intrinsic feeling of quality or meaning.
And so from that perspective, at least thankfully, I don't feel like it literally needs to be the size of something. There's this Charlie Rose interview—I actually think it's a Charlie Rose interview with David Foster Wallace—and they're talking about David Foster Wallace's writing.
Charlie Rose says Paul Cézanne, who's this painter of the past, until his dying year was obsessed with creating this big painting. Like actually scale—like a late-in-life creator type thing that just will make anybody in awe.
And so he asked David Foster Wallace, "Do you feel like that?" And he's like, "Yeah, but I think that's a different kind of thing." A painting, no matter how big it is, can be taken in all at once. The audience's relationship to the painting is still like a one-shot deal, to some extent.
But if you write a bigger and bigger book, you're literally asking the reader to—
Jackson: (56:16) Making it less likely that anyone could do it.
Anu: (56:18) Yeah. And you're telling them this is worth that much more of your time to learn and understand. Which is kind of funny because Infinite Jest ended up being long.
Jackson: (56:27) That was pre-Infinite Jest, I guess?
Anu: (56:28) Well, it was after Infinite Jest. So he kind of does self-awarely go on to say, "And by the way, yes, I also understand Infinite Jest ended up being long."
But I think there is something to that, which is maybe in the writing example or the book example, it's not so much about scale or the number of pages. It's more like, what do you feel about the quality of that thing and the impact of that thing? Whereas in the Elon example, obviously it's very much bigger, better, outer space. There's a physical component to the scale.
Jackson: (56:59) I mean, maybe to Elon's credit, there is some continuity of it. He has really been obsessed with Mars for a while.
The other place my mind was going is, I think for a certain person, they're trying to do a smattering of projects over the course of their lives. And the next thing is not only trying to make it better, but trying to do something different.
A great example of this would be this interview with Dylan—
Anu: (57:29) Dylan?
Jackson: (57:30) Bob Dylan, sorry.
Anu: (57:31) Okay.
Jackson: (57:31) Recently-ish. He's talking about the songs he wrote in the '60s and he's like, "I can't do it anymore." Like there was some magic connection or divine connection or whatever. And he's not saying, "I'm not proud of what I can do now," but there's an element of that.
On the other end you have Hokusai. I don't know if you've read much about him, but he painted The Great Wave off Kanagawa when he was like 83 and he literally was painting waves for decades. It's actually just compounding all the way. Do you have any sense of if you're more inclined to go in one of those two directions?
Anu: (58:14) It's like: are you going to keep climbing the same hill and see if you get to a bigger masterpiece?
A couple of things. So, a question you asked earlier is that I've been writing maybe less frequently in terms of Working Theorys. Some of that time is going to the book. Some of that time is also going to spending more time working with investors and founders as a writer-in-residence.
But what does that mean, exactly? I feel like writing, to me, is actually a very broad concept, even though we obviously think about it as words on a page. It's like Paul Graham and others—I don't know who actually originally said it—but they'll say writing is thinking. I think there's actually a lot of truth to that.
But I think writing is also coming up with ideas, writing is strategy, writing is comms, writing is fill-in-the-blank. It actually touches a lot of different things. I found something interesting there that I'm spending time on as well.
The reason it's interesting is because writing in the way that I write essays or write a book is a solo endeavor.
Jackson: (59:35) Got it.
Anu: (59:36) Because of all my lives of building things with other people, there is something really useful to me to be in a team on a mission doing something. It actually unlocks more creativity or different kinds of creativity.
In these environments, there is a scale element to it. It's not my scale element, but I get to be the judgment and the leverage that may impact scale, even if my goal itself with what I'm doing isn't scale. I find that to be very interesting.
Jackson: (1:00:14) You kind of get to have your cake and eat it too, which is like, "I have this big, ambitious solo project, and then I also get to be a part of..." That's a cool duality. I like that. That feels like an ideal way to combat the peril of being the lone writer who's off away.
Anu: (1:00:31) Yeah. I think writing is thinking. And if you abstract away all of those words, there's a lot of judgment that goes into writing. It's like, what is the idea? What's interesting? What's the right way to articulate it? And I think that actually is interesting inside an organization with a mission that isn't yours as well.
That's one part of the question, which is other areas that I would be spending time in. And the second part of the question is I have other kinds of ambitions with writing, which is some stuff I've written about. I like film quite a bit, and I think my ambition in film also is in a writing way.
Jackson: (1:01:07) Okay.
Anu: (1:01:08) So I want to write a book, or I'm writing a book. Maybe I want to write another book, but maybe that book is nonfiction or maybe it's actually a script. And so I think I will have projects that I'm going to be doing, but they don't necessarily feel like they all have to be the same type of project. In the wave analogy, like painting the same wave.
1:01:27 Why Media and Software
Jackson: (1:01:27) Two kind of core domains that you're using writing to move towards or that you seem to be drawn towards—maybe notwithstanding your extremely substantial medical background—are software and narrative visual media. Let's call it film plus. What about those two things draws you in?
Anu: (1:01:52) I was always drawn to media first.
Jackson: (1:01:57) And when you say media, you mean—
Anu: (1:02:00) I mean it in the broadest sense because it's like writing, reading, television, film, fashion... kind of this whole creative world that I think is like a visual media or like some sort of narrative media.
Jackson: (1:02:15) Yeah.
Anu: (1:02:16) And I think as far as software and technology goes, I think the way in which founders or builders in this ecosystem attack problems and try to create things and scale those things is very interesting. I think historically a lot of the creative domains have been very "do things that don't scale"—do things that don't scale and do things that may not even make money.
Jackson: (1:02:46) I see. So there's something about the commercial side of this artistic or creative expression that is—maybe pragmatic or practical is the wrong word, but it's—
Anu: (1:02:57) It's a different game. And I think it's probably not a game that I would only want to play, but it's a game that I enjoy playing.
Jackson: (1:03:06) Why? Because of the scale? Because of the—
Anu: (1:03:11) I think the scale is part of it. But I mean, maybe we have some shared sensibility here: I care most about consumer networks. Those are probably the things that I find the most interesting in technology. So it's still very people-oriented and very media, creation, and observation-oriented.
Jackson: (1:03:32) I agree.
Anu: (1:03:33) So it’s like, I don't think I have a universal love for every kind of mission in technology. I can certainly appreciate what it takes to do that and love being around really ambitious people.
But I wrote this piece some time ago about type one and type two entrepreneurs: mission-driven versus, basically, driven by the game.
Jackson: (1:03:55) So artist versus athlete?
Anu: (1:03:57) Kind of, yeah. In the business sense or the Silicon Valley sense. And I think I'm much more mission-driven in that way, or artist in that way. Whereas—this is the example I give—a Nikita Bier, I feel like, is a consummate gamer of this ecosystem. Give him any problem, he wants to find the solution and do it quick and fast and then do it again and sell it twice.
So I think there's overlap in this artist-creative side and this business-scale side. Because I don't like just anything in this side; I'm drawn to the things that feel like they serve more of this people-oriented, culture-oriented mission.
1:04:39 Good Premises & Social Utilities
Jackson: (1:04:39) One of my favorite theories you have is this idea of great products having great premises.
Anu: (1:04:44) Yeah. I mean, number one, I just love the word "premise."
Jackson: (1:04:49) Aesthetically?
Anu: (1:04:50) Aesthetically, yeah. And it just sounds nice and the meaning of it is something that I like. Because I feel like there is a premise when we're talking about products; there's a premise in film, there's a premise in many things. And so I think I tend to make those parallels.
The way I've articulated it in a product sense is I think the best kind of premises give a consumer permission to do something that they previously would either never have thought to do or would think is socially unsavory or even unsafe to do.
The canonical examples to me are an Airbnb. It's like, "Okay, I'm going to stay at a stranger's home while they're there"—at the beginning anyway. Like even Substack, I think, which is like, "Yeah, I'm going to build an audience and then I expect you to directly pay me for this writing, and that's normal that I'm asking you to do this."
There's an innovation in the premise that flows through not only to how you market it and brand the product and why users want to use the product, but also to the product itself. You cannot have a premise and then not have a product that fits that premise. The actual features have to have alignment there.
Jackson: (1:06:09) Oh, and they're all in service of the premise.
Anu: (1:06:10) Correct.
Jackson: (1:06:11) One of the reasons I love this so much is I had a way of talking about this for super long that wasn't as elegant, which is they're culturally normalizing something that previously—and I always use part of my background as I would always talk about Twitch in this way.
What Twitch did is it convinced people that you could pay for content that was already free. Obviously it did other things, but that was the premise. And similarly with Airbnb and Substack, it wasn't—yes, of course, all those companies built technology—but that wasn't really the thing. The thing was that you can pay writers. There were already newsletters.
Maybe the reason I'm so compelled by it too is it's not typically how we conceive of technology. Technology is more like what's mechanically possible and then it will just happen as soon as it's mechanically possible. And these examples are good slight counters.
Anu: (1:06:57) The other thing that I also like about it is that I think a lot of times we say, "Oh, it's like just talk to the users and they'll tell you what they want." And I think this is kind of a flip of that. I don't know that people would ask to stay in your house while you're there. It's like top-down normalization.
Jackson: (1:07:17) Yes. Most of software, by the way, is bottom-up.
Anu: (1:07:20) Correct. And so I think that's what I like about it so much. It kind of flips that "keep iterating with the users and you'll eventually get to it." It's more like, "No, I actually have this flip on the world and I'm going to instrument it top-down through the product and see if it works." And when it works it's actually very paradigm-changing.
Jackson: (1:07:37) Are there good premises that you've witnessed bad execution on? Yeah, ones that haven't actually come to...
Anu: (1:07:43) This is the number one thing I say about movies. Good premises, bad execution — very easy, very common in that medium.
Jackson: (1:07:52) That's a great point.
Anu: (1:07:53) One that comes to mind for that, the number one, is this movie The Invention of Lying. It's a Ricky Gervais, Jennifer Garner kind of thing.
The premise is that it's set back in time when there was no lying. Nobody even conceives of the concept of a lie, or that they could lie. So you're dropped into this world and you think, "What would a society look like?" And then one guy...
Jackson: (1:08:22) Movies like this can go both ways. I just saw two recent ones. One was The Drama, which I assume you saw?
Anu: (1:08:29) Yes. I think: good premise, fair execution.
Jackson: (1:08:31) Exactly. Meanwhile, a movie that I thought had a good premise that actually was horrible — and I think may have actually been a bad premise — was this Monica Barbaro, Callum Turner rom-com about... it's like The Purge for sex.
Anu: (1:08:43) Yeah, I think I agree with you that it may have actually been a bad premise.
Jackson: (1:08:46) It sounds like a good premise. You're like, "Oh, a movie, it's The Purge for sex." And then if you think about it at all, it's terrible.
That totally resonates in movies. I want to talk more about movies, but in software, or in this context, it also feels like we're entering a new era. There were a bunch of these in the last era of software, and then with the AI thing, there haven't really been as many, maybe.
Anu: (1:09:03) Yeah, I don't know. Maybe I'm just thinking more abstractly. It just feels like there's a lot less premises now in software.
Jackson: (1:09:11) I'll give you an example. I interviewed this guy earlier this year named Paul Scherer who's building this thing called Eigen. That's an interesting premise.
Anu: (1:09:19) Tell me more, because I know he's a mutual friend.
Jackson: (1:09:21) Paul's non-consensus view is: this thing is not a servant. It is a friend. So it's a peer. And the goal is for it to be like your seventh-best friend.
It's not trying to be your best friend. It's not trying to be this parasocial thing. But its goal is to be in your group chats and facilitate other types of social interactions and be this extra person. Which, again, I'm not sure if it's going to work. I'm not even sure it's a good premise, but it's a distinct premise.
Anu: (1:09:49) What's the premise? I guess that's my... what is the premise?
Jackson: (1:09:52) The premise is that basically social networks as they are — future ones — are not going to be in the shape of a UI with a scrolling infinite feed. They're instead going to be embodied. So this character that Paul is trying to create is...
Anu: (1:10:07) The algorithm is a person, basically.
Jackson: (1:10:09) Yes, that's the premise. You're better at this than I am. Maybe a different version would be what Avi Schiffmann is, or was, trying to do with Friend. Do you think that has a distinct premise?
Anu: (1:10:23) I feel like the premise of that is just that it's okay to talk to an AI as a friend. And I think it's not necessarily high resolution yet.
I don't know that it's specific enough. And then maybe even if it is, that doesn't mean they always work. To your point, the premise could be interesting, but if it's not actually unlocking a user behavior that people are enjoying, or the friend isn't good...
I don't mean Avi's Friend specifically; I just mean as an example. The premise could be interesting, but if the friend isn't compelling enough...
Jackson: (1:11:00) But it sounds like you're saying if the premise were better... What I'm hearing from you a little bit is like, well, people go back to old products like Path or Foursquare or Highlight — which was Paul's company before Clubhouse.
And then there's Clubhouse. I mean, maybe we should talk about that. How good was that premise? Was the premise not good enough, or was it...?
Anu: (1:11:17) I think it was a good premise.
Jackson: (1:11:18) Okay, so the execution was what failed in that?
Anu: (1:11:20) I think there's a lot of things. But I think that the original premise worked in the life where the product felt like that original premise.
There are a lot of obviously contextual things as well — environmental things like COVID, what have you. And then I think, in general, anytime you start expanding use cases and expanding networks, the actual product changes or the experience changes. So that's why I say I think the original premise worked in the original instantiation before it started expanding.
Jackson: (1:11:54) Does the premise have to evolve constantly for a product or a social network like this? In theory, Airbnb — everything else they've tried hasn't really worked that much, and the main premise really worked well.
Anu: (1:12:04) A couple things. I do think a lot of social networks that are started now-ish need a second act pretty fast. Maybe not ten years ago, so there is a whole time-cycle thing.
Jackson: (1:12:15) Like BeReal. Maybe not that that's recent, but it is recent-ish.
Anu: (1:12:19) Yeah, the first act was great for about a year. And if you're not already thinking about the second act before that, then I think it becomes really hard.
I would also then argue that maybe the original premise itself was a feature and not a fully embodied idea. So I feel like you could answer this both ways: you could say the execution wasn't good, or you could say the fact that the execution wasn't good just means the premise wasn't good enough to begin with.
Jackson: (1:12:46) You've talked about social utilities. I could say that, on the margin, most social utilities have that exact same problem, which is that it's a feature.
Anu: (1:12:58) Give me an example.
Anu: (1:13:00) Okay, but it's working.
Jackson: (1:13:01) Is it working? Is it a big business?
Anu: (1:13:06) Well, I guess we have to define what "working" is.
Jackson: (1:13:10) Fair. I don't mean to... Partiful is a great product. I think BeReal is a really cool product. BeReal is really big. But...
Anu: (1:13:18) I feel like, actually, with those two examples, we're looking at the curve. I think the reason we say BeReal failed is because it kind of fell off, whereas I don't think we're saying Partiful fell off. We're just saying it hasn't gotten big enough fast enough.
Jackson: (1:13:28) My contention is I think Partiful in the end will have the same problem BeReal had, which is that there's something structural about it that's too narrow for it to really become this...
Anu: (1:13:38) But I think the difference there is I think Partiful could continue to exist successfully and grow for a long time because the core is a utility. Whereas the core of BeReal is not a utility.
There is an actual utilitarian feature that Partiful is providing, whereas with BeReal, it's not exactly utilitarian.
Jackson: (1:13:59) Are you as excited about this social utility frame as you were three years ago?
Anu: (1:14:04) Yes. I just think because of the AI wave right now, the way we're talking about products is a lot different. But I do think that a lot of the social products that have grown and persisted are social utilities.
Jackson: (1:14:21) Can you define what a social utility is real quick?
Anu: (1:14:23) It's a tool that you use with a social graph or a social group you already have.
Jackson: (1:14:29) You're bringing your friends, you're using the tool with them.
Anu: (1:14:32) Or a community or an organization, what have you. So you're not creating a net-new graph from scratch because of this product.
And those two things allow such that, one, there's a utility, so you don't need to prove or unlock a new consumer behavior. Two, you already have a group of people for which that thing is useful together.
And you know that you have affinity for the people, as opposed to joining a new social app and not knowing what your affinity is for the people on that graph. So Partiful, Locket, Retro—those are all kind of canonical social utilities to me. Those are all quite successful, but may—
Jackson: (1:15:12) Not be... All of those aren't successful.
Anu: (1:15:14) Right. So I think we're just talking about the scale of them becoming like social networks.
Jackson: (1:15:22) Maybe it's worth me actually... I certainly think all of those are really thoughtful products that have worked in some way. It's the area of software that you and I are interested in, which we broadly call this intersection of internet media, consumer-y type stuff.
Basically, I was a junior in college and I helped bring Musical.ly into Universal Music Group, and nothing has happened since.
Anu: (1:15:42) Yeah.
Jackson: (1:15:43) In 2016, 2015, obviously that became TikTok. There was Discord.
Anu: (1:15:48) It's crazy that your frame is that nothing has happened since.
Jackson: (1:15:52) Sorry. Obviously plenty has happened, but really what I mean is nothing happened between then and ChatGPT from a big consumer thing. Maybe Discord. Is the reason we haven't had another really, truly big consumer thing something so structural in the water that it was just not possible, or that there hasn't been a good enough premise?
Anu: (1:16:10) That's a good question.
Jackson: (1:16:12) Like if there was really a better idea.
Anu: (1:16:15) Are all the premises gone? Are they all done?
Jackson: (1:16:16) Of course I don't think so, and I doubt you do too. But is it an idea problem or is it a structural problem?
Anu: (1:16:22) Yeah, I mean, of course I want to say it's an idea problem, but I do think there is a structural thing too. I think it has something to do with the infinite competition for time that people now have—like 10x even ten years ago or five years ago—such that it kind of makes it hard for any new thing to be sticky.
Unless—and this is also part of my thing—I think with the ChatGPTs and stuff, this whole new wave I actually bet on is very utilitarian.
Jackson: (1:16:59) Ah. Okay.
Anu: (1:17:00) It's very...
Jackson: (1:17:01) Social utility of true, true, really large scale.
Anu: (1:17:08) I think that...
Jackson: (1:17:09) Maybe Instinct?
Anu: (1:17:10) I think that right now it's going to be the reverse order, which is going to be utility first and then become social. Like Instinct. Yeah, I just posted about this the other day, which is their trusted person network and then now the group chat.
It's clearly escape velocity as a personal utility, but it can easily become social, especially when it's in messaging.
Jackson: (1:17:31) Right, right. But it's a little inverted from the classic network effect.
Anu: (1:17:35) Correct. And I think with ChatGPT it's a little bit harder because the social utility there on a web productivity app is what—Google Docs? We don't really have that, or like Microsoft Teams or something like iMessage.
Messaging is such a more native place to layer on social media than in a work or productivity environment. Unless you go inside the org, and then it's not really social in the way we're talking about. It's more like enterprise.
Jackson: (1:17:59) Yeah, yeah.
Anu: (1:18:01) But maybe we'll find a good premise.
Jackson: (1:18:04) Just missing the great premise.
1:18:07 Art & Sport
Jackson: (1:18:07) The other thing that came to mind in what we were discussing earlier is this art-sport frame you have.
I think most interestingly to me, you describe entrepreneurship as being the place where those two things come together. Why is that juncture such a mix of art and sport?
Anu: (1:18:29) I think in the traditional sense, when we think about sports, there's a very clear rule set and a very clear way to play the game. And I think in art, there are no rules.
Jackson: (1:18:39) This is where the ambiguity is.
Anu: (1:18:42) Right. And I think entrepreneurship is like neither extreme. So just by nature... I mean, there's laws of business, right? And laws of products in some sense and laws of markets that entrepreneurs have to play by. But—
Jackson: (1:18:59) But it's more artistic than most parts of business.
Anu: (1:19:02) Yeah, it wouldn't be entrepreneurship if it was a sport, because a sport is so hierarchically and linearly defined. Any sport, in a literal sense, it's like: "Here's the rules, this is exactly what you have to do to get one step or one place higher than the next person."
Then it's not really entrepreneurial. It's just hierarchy or ranking. I feel like entrepreneurship is about skipping the line somehow by finding... it's that canonical Y Combinator question: "Tell me about a time you hacked some non-computer system to get an advantage."
That's antithetical to sport. You're not supposed to hack anything in sport per se.
Jackson: (1:19:50) Okay, that makes sense to me. Also I should caveat, you have a great talk with Sana on art and sport, and the premise being that sort of any skill on the long enough time horizon post-AI is going to go the way of extinction, art, or sport.
We often talk about athletes, like true greatness, as artistic—Federer you imagine, Steph Curry. Am I trying too hard, or is there some tension inside of that?
Anu: (1:20:11) Meaning there's an art there.
Jackson: (1:20:13) Yeah.
Anu: (1:20:16) No, you're not trying too hard. I think there is an artistry in how you play a sport. But the game itself is very bounded, structured, like no ambiguity.
So the objective functions they're all trying to get to are similar, of course. But sure, there's some artistry in how they do it. Federer is very classically called effortless and elegant, and that's the thing. And then he will also tell you, "Don't call it that. It's through a lot of effort and a lot of practice."
In a graduation speech he gave, he said something to the effect of he maybe only won 52% of points and lost 48%. And he's the greatest player of all time, or at least in that conversation, right?
So there's a lot of things in there where the narrative that comes out about how artistic or elegant or superior athletes are compared to others is very binary. It's forced to be binary because sport itself is so binary.
Jackson: (1:21:18) Whereas you never do that in art. We try to do these stupid lists for movies, but it's like, actually—
Anu: (1:21:22) Right.
Jackson: (1:21:22) As you were giving an example, one of my favorite quotes ever is from Jerry Seinfeld. He says, "All art is disguising work." It's the same idea.
I was going to say, is there an element of this where the inverse is true? Where there are aspects of really great artists that are kind of—yeah.
Anu: (1:21:35) One of my favorite and common art quotes is, "Art is what you can get away with," right?
Jackson: (1:21:40) Ah.
Anu: (1:21:41) You can't get away with a lot in sport.
Jackson: (1:21:43) Wow, I like that. Yeah. How did you get to this?
Anu: (1:21:48) Get to what?
Jackson: (1:21:49) This little model theory.
Anu: (1:21:52) Certainly it was accelerated by this whole conversation around AI. Coding is this big high-skill thing, and now it's not.
So in my mind, I'm like, okay, what is the future of coding? Does coding become something we just don't do anymore, or are there people who would still want to do it for some reason? If they want to do it for some reason, why?
Jackson: (1:22:17) Would they do it for sport or art?
Anu: (1:22:19) Or art. There's a craft version of it, which is the art version, and there's a sport version which is literally like chess. Computers can play chess, but we still play chess as a sport.
Jackson: (1:22:30) We play chess more. Right.
Anu: (1:22:31) Right. We want to see humans test their limits. And for better or worse, we like hierarchies and lists and moving up or down those lists, seeing humans push their limits and try to just be great.
Jackson: (1:22:49) Yeah.
Anu: (1:22:49) And I don't think that ever goes away. So the thing that they're doing might be different. I think in the most ambiguous form, it's art, and in the least ambiguous form, it's sport.
Jackson: (1:23:00) Right. You have this frame there where artists have ambiguity in the work and athletes have ambiguity in the environment or the competition.
Anu: (1:23:07) Yeah.
Jackson: (1:23:08) It's this kind of yin-yang. I like that.
1:23:10 Differently Free
Jackson: (1:23:10) In that list of recs, you also recommended this essay from Venkatesh on not surrounding yourself with smarter people.
I had no idea that it was actually this piece that had been referenced by Henrik Karlsson, who's been on this podcast before, around people who are "differently free" than you. I realized I think I read part of it, but I hadn't read the whole thing. It's so amazing. There are actually so many different ideas in here.
How much intentionality do you put in, and how do you think about intentionality when it comes to the people you surround yourself with? And maybe as a cut on that, what are the ways that people who have been really differently free than you have been helpful?
Anu: (1:23:49) I don't think I actually think too much about wanting a specific type of person around me, but I think that I learn pretty quickly if I enjoy spending time with a person. And that's my primary filter.
But there are a lot of elements that could go into that. Number one is just the conversation itself. It's not always that the first time you meet somebody is going to be the best conversation you'll have with someone.
Jackson: (1:24:13) The first time you meet someone will be the best conversation?
Anu: (1:24:16) I'm saying it's not always the case, but—
Jackson: (1:24:18) That's kind of the aspiration, is the implication.
Anu: (1:24:20) Well, the reason I'm saying that is because a lot of how I judge if I want to spend time with a person is based on the conversation.
Jackson: (1:24:27) It sets the bar, actually. Right.
Anu: (1:24:29) Right. And so it's great if the first conversation is phenomenal, and if not, I may be discounting the value of that thing until the next time that I end up talking to that person.
But all that is just to say that I think conversation, and how much I enjoy that conversation for some number of reasons, is probably the primary thing that determines if I want to spend time with them.
Jackson: (1:24:48) How many people you really enjoy conversation with are not materially differently free than you? Also, just to maybe quickly clarify: "differently free," how would you describe that in your own words?
Anu: (1:24:58) I think each one of us has some sorts of constraints or things that hold us back, or things we're more or less afraid of, or just how we view the world or engage in the world.
Let's say I don't want to spend money, and I'm always thrifty. And you're like, "It's just money. Let's go out, have a great dinner, it's fine, we'll just make more money, or we're already making enough money, we don't need to save it."
That would be an example of you being differently free than me. That could be grating if I don't want to spend money, but also can be very freeing if this attribute of myself is not something that I really like that much, which I think is a common thing for people who introspect about their constraints.
Jackson: (1:25:43) Yes.
Anu: (1:25:44) So your question was, how are they differently free?
Jackson: (1:25:48) How are you intentionally thinking about the people you're surrounded by?
Anu: (1:25:51) Well, one, I like conversations where people are willing to challenge me. I don't know if that means they're necessarily differently free than me, but they're certainly not exactly the same as me just by the fact that their opinions would be different enough. And then they'd be willing to challenge me.
Jackson: (1:26:10) I would suspect that if they're good at challenging you, it is rooted in some differently freeness.
Anu: (1:26:18) Yes, for sure.
Jackson: (1:26:18) Some people are just combative, but—
Anu: (1:26:20) Yeah, for sure. I think on balance, I skew more thinker. So it's nice when there are more feelers. I think in the meta, it’s nice when there are people who are just doing the thing. They're in the present.
I think that's a kind of freedom, actually—a freedom from observing the thing while you're doing the thing.
Jackson: (1:26:46) He describes it in the piece as sort of one of the meta-themes: freedom to win versus freedom to keep playing. That seems like a version of that, I think.
Anu: (1:26:56) Probably. When I read the frame, I was like, "That's definitely true." As far as who I care to have around me, I don't care that they're smarter than me necessarily, or that I'm smarter than them, although I care that the conversation is intellectually satisfying.
Jackson: (1:27:16) Ironically, "surround yourself with people smarter than you" is like a low-fidelity proxy trying to say what he really says in this piece.
Anu: (1:27:24) Yeah, right. Because the thing is, I don't often think people are smarter than me because I literally think that there's some sort of IQ smarter. I think they're smarter than me because something they're differently free about makes them smarter in life.
Jackson: (1:27:39) Yes. They're looser, they're whatever.
Anu: (1:27:41) Right, correct. So it actually kind of does work for the "smarter" frame, but just not in the way we usually use it.
Jackson: (1:27:48) Yes.
Anu: (1:27:49) Yeah. What about you? You have to tell me—what's yours?
Jackson: (1:27:53) Which—differently free? Like, am I seeking it?
Anu: (1:27:56) Well, what is "differently free" for you? Which I guess imputes: what are your constraints?
Jackson: (1:28:00) The biggest anchor I have for that idea is because it came from Henrik. I had just interviewed Henrik. We had spent six or seven hours together walking around Copenhagen and doing an interview. It was the second time I interviewed him, so we'd spent some time together.
Henrik is a couple years older than me, but he joked like we could be cousins. I'm a quarter Swedish, he's Swedish. On the surface, not that different. And our lives are so different.
He has a nine-year-old and a five-year-old. He lives on a tiny island in Denmark. He interacts with a very small amount of people. I live in New York City. I do not have a family.
He is very constrained and very focused. I am very free in this sort of optionality sense. I mean, he's a genius, so it's been valuable for me to get to spend time with him in general.
But I think it's been maybe invaluable in that we're really cross-sectioning. Part of it is maybe like, "Wow, that's just an alternative version of my life." But—
Anu: (1:29:01) But in this example, it seems like it's very clear how you are differently free than him. How is he differently free than you?
Jackson: (1:29:08) Oh, it's a great question. It's a little bit complicated because I have more options. I have more...
Anu: (1:29:14) Yeah, but options are not always freedom.
Jackson: (1:29:16) Of course. So one of the things I've really learned over the past small amount of time is that almost everything good in life comes from commitments. There is actually a different type of freedom that comes from commitments.
Anu: (1:29:26) That was Nicole's episode.
Jackson: (1:29:27) Right. One of the big ways I connect to this is there's a phrase that I think about a lot in lots of contexts that I at least got from a guy named Graham Duncan. And Graham uses the phrase "a loose grip."
What I really connect to this idea with is that Henrik has a loose grip on things that I have a firm grip on, and vice versa. That allows him to see with clarity. In a way that when we were walking around, he's just like, "You can just do this," or, "You don't have to do this."
As a broad meta point, it's a lot of like I'm not seeing the water, and he's like, "The water's right here, dude." And that, I think, is how I relate to the experience of being differently free.
I certainly relate to the idea you brought up, too, which I think is one of—if not the primary—virtues of friendship: people who can tell you the things that no one else in the world can tell you, that you don't want to hear, because they have this way of getting in there.
Anu: (1:30:19) I think "differently freeness" is also very zoom-out or zoom-in.
Jackson: (1:30:24) Ah.
Anu: (1:30:25) I think people who feel differently free than you take the thing that you're calibrated at a certain level on, and they often have a zoom-out or zoom-in perspective.
Jackson: (1:30:35) I think I know what you mean. Can you give me an example? They're at a different level of abstraction, so they just see a different perspective?
Anu: (1:30:40) Right. Or maybe that's a value they're providing by taking you out of where you're calibrated on the thing.
Jackson: (1:30:47) That's—
Anu: (1:30:47) Right. And they're naturally set there, which is why you guys aren't just fixating on the same things.
Jackson: (1:30:52) As a very basic thing, the reason this concept is so good is because life would be so easy if you were anything other than the person that you are. I think about this a lot.
This is a dumb example, but there's this YouTube channel called Turning the Tables, I think it's called. It's a father and son, and they listen to music. They're listening to an Olivia Rodrigo album, and she sings—I think the lyric is, "I'm so tired of being the girl that I am."
And the father goes, "I'm a 50-year-old dude. I have nothing in common with Olivia Rodrigo, but I can so deeply relate to that lyric." Everyone can relate to that lyric. Because everything that makes us good or genius has the foil. And so if you were anyone other than you, your problems would not be hard. They're so easy.
Anu: (1:31:35) That's what it feels like.
Jackson: (1:31:36) Obviously, that doesn't always apply. But at the very least, it's why you can sometimes be stuck and you're like, "Oh, I don't need to talk to anyone about this. I'm just stuck. I'm going to solve it." Then you mention it to somebody and they're just like, "Oh, have you tried...?"
Anu: (1:31:51) Because they're not stuck in your past and your future. Usually, that's my articulation. They don't have the baggage of your past and they don't have the fear of your future, so they can actually look at it somewhat objectively.
Jackson: (1:32:04) And they just start looking at it from a slightly different angle. It's like you're looking at a 2D maze, and you could just rotate it a little bit and be like, "Oh, I can literally just walk around."
Anu: (1:32:14) Yeah. I feel like maybe "differently free" to me now is feeling differently calibrated on a given thing. Obviously, "differently free" is a much more elegant explanation, but if I were to try to dig deeper into that—
Jackson: (1:32:26) That makes sense.
1:32:26 Writing with AI
Jackson: (1:32:26) Moving quickly to a few things on AI. One line that really stood out is: "We mistake activity for agency."
You say, before long you're not thinking deeply, but rather half-attentively negotiating with a machine that never runs out of suggestions. "Have you considered...?" "Would you like me to...?" "Shall I go ahead and...?" This slot machine's lever is one question: "Continue?" Have you found ways to get out of this?
Anu: (1:32:58) It's very painful hearing it. It takes me into the experience of—
Jackson: (1:33:02) We've all been there. If you're not there, you just haven't used these tools enough, frankly. And if you think it doesn't apply to you... I was about to imply I'm wrong because I have my own version of the psychosis, even if I'm making fun of my friends.
How do you balance the magic and the sanity?
Anu: (1:33:23) Unfortunately, like with all technology, I feel like it's a lot of trial and error. You end up going too far in one direction and then you're like, "This doesn't feel good."
Jackson: (1:33:32) Yeah.
Anu: (1:33:33) And so, obviously, with models changing so frequently, there's an external component of that as well. So it's some combination of those two things.
I think I've probably just calibrated over time what things it feels useful—and then feels good—to use them for. There's some matrix there of: what is it useful for or not useful for? And: what does it feel good?
Jackson: (1:33:57) Feels good during, or feels good after?
Anu: (1:34:01) After.
Jackson: (1:34:01) Okay.
Anu: (1:34:02) Yeah. I think "feel good during" is a very murky situation, simply because of what I was saying.
Jackson: (1:34:08) Maybe the reason I distinguish is that I don't think I really feel good while I'm scrolling social media.
Anu: (1:34:13) Sure.
Jackson: (1:34:14) I’m addicted.
Anu: (1:34:15) Sure.
Jackson: (1:34:16) The distinction here is actually that first line I said, which is mistaking activity for agency. I have a lot of friends who are like, "I’m late for dinner because I gotta keep prompting."
And that is something where it actually can feel like you’re being productive. Only after, when you have the distance, you’re like, "Whoa, I was—"
Anu: (1:34:31) Right. But that’s what I’m saying. I think when you ask me the question of whether it’s during or after, I want to calibrate on the after. Because during, you’re kind of in the psychosis. By that I mean somebody else is pulling you along.
Jackson: (1:34:44) You’re like, "I’m doing great. I’m making things. I’m making things."
Anu: (1:34:46) Correct. Hence my realization is post facto: How do you feel about that thing?
And so, if I give the example of writing, I think that AI is inevitably going to be used in writing in some parts of the process. I have used it in some parts of the process, but there are certainly some parts of it that you just don't want to use it in. Even figuring that out is a process of discovery to some extent.
Jackson: (1:35:13) What have you discovered?
Anu: (1:35:14) I think that it’s quite good for research. It’s quite good for even brain dumping thoughts and having it organize things—very simple things like that. I think of that as upstream.
I think it’s pretty good downstream for asking for critique. So, critique it based on the style that I usually write. Critique it based on somebody else’s style. Tell me what’s great, tell me what’s not great, or tell me what doesn’t make sense? Those sorts of things. I think it gets murky if you ask it for edits.
Jackson: (1:35:45) It sounds like it gets murky if you—so you’re saying critique, like qualitative critique?
Anu: (1:35:50) Correct.
Jackson: (1:35:51) Like, "What do you think of this?" Not, "Go make line edits."
Anu: (1:35:54) Right. That being said, I think that’s the murkiest place because I do think that there’s some generativeness of AI that actually becomes a prompt for you.
If you say, "suggest an edit" and it’s like, "here’s an idea for something," that idea that it gives you can actually generate a thought in you that’s interesting. But the counter to that is if you actually just use it to make edits, it usually removes a lot of quality and a lot of thinking.
Jackson: (1:36:28) Great distinction.
Anu: (1:36:29) So—
Jackson: (1:36:30) I don’t know how broadly it applies beyond writing, but at least in the writing...
Anu: (1:36:33) Sure. Honestly, it probably applies in coding to some extent.
Jackson: (1:36:36) But in the coding...
Anu: (1:36:37) More mathematical.
Jackson: (1:36:38) It’s doing all the coding. Right?
Anu: (1:36:40) Right. So I think that’s the hard part. I’m able to say that I think it has some possibly positive generative qualities in terms of prompting people to think.
Jackson: (1:36:50) Well, it’s sort of like, maybe you should say to the thing, "Prompt me back. Don’t make the change. Prompt me back."
Anu: (1:36:55) Absolutely. A lot of times I’m like, "Ask me questions based on an idea I’m having."
Jackson: (1:37:01) Yeah.
Anu: (1:37:02) And then I want to answer the questions to elicit from myself more of my own thinking in different ways. And I think that’s actually quite useful. So what’s the original question?
Jackson: (1:37:14) How do you resist psychosis?
Anu: (1:37:16) Yeah. How do you resist? I mean...
Jackson: (1:37:18) Without opting out entirely? Because I think the alternative is like, "I’m not gonna." Ironically, we were just in the break speaking about the Luca Guadagnino movie Artificial, and there was an interview that came out.
Anu: (1:37:29) He said, "I use no AI always."
Jackson: (1:37:30) Right. "Because I learned about this, I’m not going to use it at all." And it’s like, well, okay. But I think the interesting disposition is almost never all or nothing.
Anu: (1:37:42) Yeah. It can’t be, because eventually it always catches up. I think for whatever the craft you’re working on is, you kind of have to have your own understanding of what parts of it you think are a craft that you want to hold on to versus not.
At least as far as writing goes, I kind of feel like you know at which point it’s helping you be better at the thing versus replacing the thing that you’re doing. I do agree that it’s going to get harder over time to be able to distinguish.
Jackson: (1:38:10) It just matters if it’s instrumental for you or not. In your case, writing is not only craft, but I think it’s way harder when somebody hasn’t fully internalized this idea of, "I’m writing for myself."
Anu: (1:38:23) Right.
Jackson: (1:38:23) I was talking to Jasmine Sun, and she’s like, "I’m writing to get smarter." And it’s like, well, most people aren’t. Most people are writing because they have to write something, or coding because they have to. So I think that’s the other part that’s hard—being self-aware enough to be like...
Anu: (1:38:34) Yeah. I mean, but in those cases, for example, company writing is becoming a big topic. Should you use AI in company writing? It kind of seems like maybe you should because there’s just so much that’s about the information and not the prose.
At the same time, if you just feed that into an LLM, I don’t want to be getting these "clanked out" documents. Even though people feel like you can use AI in that type of writing, I think the hesitation there is that you’re putting a burden on the reader if you don’t use it thoughtfully enough.
Jackson: (1:39:08) Yeah.
Anu: (1:39:08) It’s like an asymmetry of...
Jackson: (1:39:12) Extracting my time. Right.
Anu: (1:39:13) Yeah. I call it the effort gap. I’m kind of insulting you by being like, "I’m going to spend no time on this, but I want you to spend a bunch of time reading this expansive document that I created simply to look like I created something expansive."
Jackson: (1:39:28) Put it like that, it’s pretty brutal.
Anu: (1:39:30) Maybe not so intentionally, but I think that’s the effect.
Jackson: (1:39:32) I think that’s right.
1:39:32 Media and Machines
Jackson: (1:39:32) The final human edge will be in controlling the machine or just keeping your distance.
Talking about all or nothing, you say every organization will now operate as half media, half machine. Every media company will have a head of machines; every machine company will have a head of media. Call it the media machine singularity of business, the hybrid imperative.
Then you also go on to say, "Transmission and virality without virtue isn't progress, but social and cultural vandalism. And this burns through meaning to fuel empty engagement."
And one final quote from that piece: "Our ultimate test will be one of tactical mastery, editorial skill, and judgment. The courage to feed the machine something better than its own reflex." Do you think that, for most of us, it is about swinging to one end of this pendulum and getting really good at machine or getting really good at media? Or is it about integration?
Anu: (1:40:27) It’s probably integration, simply by the fact that I’m actually saying this is a fusion of these two things. One of the suggestions is that they don’t exist as successfully on their own.
Jackson: (1:40:39) Ah.
Anu: (1:40:41) So even in, like, the company example—and I think I like the elegance of the framing—but I also do think it has borne out to be true, this idea that every machine company is going to have a head of media and every media company is going to have a head of machines. And the elegant way to say it is that AI Frontier Labs are just as focused on their media.
Jackson: (1:41:01) Not only that, but Sam himself is trying to get better at the media part of it.
Anu: (1:41:05) Absolutely. That and then also in a more poetic sense, I also think all of these models are trained on a corpus of media language or human-created messages in many cases. So it's elegant in many ways that the machines are basically being trained on the media and the leaders of these machines are very focused on the media as well.
Similarly, if you look at media companies now, it's like they all have to figure out, "Oh, what are we going to do with AI? How do we deal with distribution?" Distribution networks and platforms—there's no media without an awareness of distribution or platforms or technology anymore.
Jackson: (1:41:49) It's always been the case. Is the machine part of it just more on the nose now?
Anu: (1:41:54) I think it's always been the case, but I think it just is accelerated and fused. I think the way I articulate it is that social networks were kind of the big step change in that because every user became a participant and every piece of media that was created also fed the machine, which is the platform.
Jackson: (1:42:14) I was going to say, is there a conceptual underpinning? Again, the words "media" and "machine" literally work in this case, but what is the conceptual underpinning under each of those words?
Anu: (1:42:23) It's something to go to the end, which is like the hard thing now is going to be to decide what you actually want to do. I think that the media aspect here is about story, narrative, to some extent meaning, and being very people-oriented. And I think the machine aspect here is like the things that we create that can kind of take a life of their own.
Even though I don't believe in sentience and that AI and machines are going to have souls, they do ultimately end up running a lot of our culture and our society. So it's this: is technology downstream of culture or culture downstream of technology?
And I think the closer these two things get, the harder it is for us to see the distinction which we historically have seen. And I think that's the challenge. So I don't think it's so much that I'm saying go to one or go to the other. It's more like be hyper-aware that these two are now the same. So what you do in either regard is like the self-fulfilling prophecy to some extent. Does that make sense?
Jackson: (1:43:36) Yes.
Anu: (1:43:38) So maybe it's a bit more of a cautionary tale of the trajectory versus...
Jackson: (1:43:45) And don't try to see them in isolation either.
Anu: (1:43:47) Correct.
1:43:48 Insider Media
Jackson: (1:43:48) Speaking of technology and culture, you have a great piece on insider media. "Insider media is the opposite of journalistic media—outsider media made for outsiders by outsiders. Outsiders will call insider media an echo chamber or a bubble, but the proximity is very much the product."
We could have a whole conversation about technology getting more self-aware about it being a culture and being more cultural. I think it's not in the piece—it might actually be in the one on TBPN post-acquisition—but you talk about how tech, unlike most other cultures, is super meta-aware.
Anu: (1:44:27) Yeah.
Jackson: (1:44:28) You say, "When your audience is mostly composed of high-value insiders, they're almost certainly watching the metagame as much as they're using the product. This is why 'going viral on X is valuable but not indicative of PMF with normal people.'"
Can you unpack this a little bit more? Because I actually hadn't ever thought about it this way, and I think this perfectly explains why Twitter—at least tech Twitter—is such a distinct part of the world.
Anu: (1:44:53) Well, certainly on the PMF part, social products is a great example of this. If you are a consumer social builder and you want to launch a social product, launching it on Twitter is like one of the worst places you could launch it in terms of true PMF.
Because the type of users you need and the behavior you need is typically a younger audience that's somewhere else and has more edge-case behavior than...
Jackson: (1:45:13) More women.
Anu: (1:45:13) Yeah. You know, it's the Nikita Bier playbook.
Jackson: (1:45:21) One Instagram user is more than—
Anu: (1:45:21) Right, or Snap users or TikTok or wherever your users are. But it's so tempting still to do it because your peers and the people that I consider high-value insiders in the Silicon Valley ecosystem hang out on Twitter.
And so going viral there, even if that doesn't get you PMF for the product, actually does end up being net valuable to you as a person inside this community because you gain credibility for being a person who's able to maybe get attention or launch something interesting or is just shipping.
You can kind of look at it any way. I think for other stuff that's like maybe launching media—which has been a big aspect of tech Twitter recently as well—it's like launching a show, and in that case, the audience actually is tech Twitter to some extent.
Jackson: (1:46:10) Speaking to the insiders, right?
Anu: (1:46:11) Yeah, right. So it's actually more indicative of PMF when it comes to media that is by the insiders for insiders.
Jackson: (1:46:20) Assuming you're not deluding yourself into thinking you're actually going to get some much wider audience. If anything, TBPN's ultimate genius was realizing that. They said it to me when I interviewed them: it's like a hundred thousand people or 200,000 people—we only care about them.
Anu: (1:46:32) True. So yeah, I wrote about that in both pieces, but my framing for that is that the audience market cap for you is what matters, not the audience size. And that market cap might be calculated differently depending on what industry or what audience you're looking at.
But yes, 10,000 of the CEOs of all of the companies in Silicon Valley and the investors and high-value operators and maybe the adjacent people we respect in Hollywood and what have you is infinitely more valuable than just 10,000 loosely affiliated random strangers that maybe are in the YouTube comments or something like that.
I also think that just by the fact that it's insiders to insiders, there's so many different types of value that you can gain that isn't just the success of the product that you're putting out.
Jackson: (1:47:22) Right, which is like: this is interesting about how it's made.
Anu: (1:47:26) Right. Okay, so like you started this podcast, right? I would argue that it's somewhat insider—not entirely insider, but I think that some of the guests certainly appeal to maybe what I would consider to be insiders in this ecosystem.
And the podcast is doing well, and the podcast is great, but it's also really valuable for you to have relationships with the people that are inside this community. And that may not be the case if you are starting a podcast about, I don't know, let's fill in the blank.
Jackson: (1:48:01) Or just a less deliberately specific focus on a specific audience. Right.
Anu: (1:48:05) Correct. But by that I mean you share enough similarities with the people you are interviewing and the audience.
Jackson: (1:48:13) Right, right.
Anu: (1:48:14) In terms of—
Jackson: (1:48:15) It’s distinctly different from journalism, to your comment. Correct.
Anu: (1:48:18) Correct. I remember I was talking to a journalist a couple of weeks ago a little bit about this, but in the frame of an AI frontier lab kind of media conversation, which obviously has been somewhat tenuous.
I think the perception often is that insider media is interesting because insiders don't trust journalists or they don't trust outsiders. I think that's partially true, but that's a negative frame.
There is a positive frame of why insider media is interesting as well. The analogy I have is if you look at sports, there's a lot more commentators now that are former coaches or former players or in some way are practitioners of that thing itself.
Jackson: (1:49:02) Yes.
Anu: (1:49:02) I wouldn't look at that and say it's because athletes don't trust sports journalists. Roughly speaking, I would say it's also the case that it's really maybe more interesting in some cases to have a conversation with someone who has done the thing that you are doing.
Jackson: (1:49:19) Tony Romo will predict what the play is going to be before it even happens on the field. It's a level of finger feel and knowledge.
Anu: (1:49:23) Right. There's shared context, shared knowledge, and shared emotional experiences.
Jackson: (1:49:28) This is like your cultural power player thing.
Anu: (1:49:31) Yeah, to some extent. I mean, that's about how good those individual people are at that thing. But certainly a dimension of competence might be what I'm trying—there's an insider competence that's different than an outsider competence.
Jackson: (1:49:42) Dwarkesh can do things within it. He can talk about it—part of it is how smart he is and his rigor, but a huge part of it is he's actually in that world.
Anu: (1:49:49) For sure. Tech has gotten a little bit too much of a bad rap for being antagonistic to journalists and not trusting journalists. I think it's easy to paint the insider media emergence in tech as part of that thing.
Jackson: (1:50:02) Great distinction.
Anu: (1:50:02) And I would say yes, somewhat. But also there's actually this other really positive thing.
Jackson: (1:50:09) By the way, they are super antagonistic, but it's both of those things.
Anu: (1:50:13) Yeah, maybe not all of them are. But also it's this other thing, which is that it just so happens that inside this ecosystem, there's enough value in only speaking to the insiders such that the positive aspects of insider media seem economically rational.
Jackson: (1:50:32) By the way, that was probably true in other sectors in the past.
Anu: (1:50:34) Right.
Jackson: (1:50:35) Right. In Hollywood, when Hollywood was king.
Anu: (1:50:42) Probably. It's economically rational for insider media and entertainment-wise rational as well. It’s not just about trust or distrust.
Jackson: (1:50:53) Great frame.
1:50:57 The Great Movie Theory
Jackson: (1:50:57) We've been waiting all conversation to talk about movies. Let's talk about movies.
Anu: (1:50:59) Let's talk about movies.
Jackson: (1:51:00) My heroes have always been closer to writer-directors than to traditional tech founders. What's the great movie theory?
Anu: (1:51:12) First of all, that is an example of a theory that isn't one of my most popular, but it's one of my favorites.
So you know the Great Man Theory, right? Which is, very roughly speaking, that great men are the ones who shape history and are the source or the origin of greatness and great things that happen.
Jackson: (1:51:33) Worth noting in particular contrast to the view that it's actually communities and no individual—can an individual really move things?
Anu: (1:51:41) Right, that there's a singular great person that drives a big change or something of significance that impacts history.
And so my reframe of that, which is I think a bit spiritual but also logical, is that a lot of great men or people in general are actually themselves inspired by great stories and often great movies.
We have a lot of examples of this in the childhoods of extraordinary people where we hear about movies they were particularly drawn to or stories that they were particularly drawn to.
I think like Palmer Luckey, Elon Musk, Sam Altman—they all have some shape of a story that was very compelling to them that feels very in line with the type of work that they end up doing or the way they approach doing those things.
So my theory, a little bit tongue in cheek but also logically, is that great movies or great stories are the things that influence or inspire great men to go on to do the great things that they do.
And maybe even more broadly, my leap is that all creation is aspiring to cinematic legacy in some sense.
Jackson: (1:52:57) I would agree with that. My response would be that I think in the moment we're in, you're right.
I think the generalized theory would actually be a theory of myth or a theory of story. In the past it wouldn't have been movies. There's something about—and by the way, this might not be the case in 50 years.
Anu: (1:53:14) Yeah, I think the form factor can be substituted out. But I think fundamentally, what is the form factor now?
Jackson: (1:53:19) Story.
Anu: (1:53:22) Correct. Story, or something that embodies a myth.
And I do think there's a little bit of something counterintuitive even—I do believe it's a movie right now, but I think people would argue movies are so gone. But I don't believe that.
Jackson: (1:53:35) My argument is—I'm hopeful—but my argument is in 25 years it might be the Great TikTok Theory. I'm just kidding.
Anu: (1:53:42) I don't think it will be.
Jackson: (1:53:43) It probably won't be, because it has to be heavy, right? The point is it's a heavy story or myth. Why is The Social Network the perfect film about ambition?
Anu: (1:53:54) That's my intuitive feel. Let me analyze it. It just has the elements that you want.
Well, one, it's about friends that start something together. And I think often you don't view friendships as particularly transactional or opportunistic.
If you take a story of friendship and then explode it out to the scale of The Social Network and the way they depicted the fracturing of that friendship, it feels like ambition is the exploding vector from start to finish.
It's a serious drama that is very enjoyable, but has the elements of everything and is very focused on ambition as a central theme. Modern ambition.
Jackson: (1:54:43) I think there are a number of things in this category.
Anu: (1:54:47) Do you disagree?
Jackson: (1:54:51) No, no.
Anu: (1:54:52) It’s superlative.
Jackson: (1:54:53) I certainly agree with Tarantino. Technically it isn't a movie of the 2010s because the 2010s started in 2011, but I think it's the best movie of the decade.
There is a class of film, though, that is about obsession and ambition. I would put Whiplash in this category.
Anu: (1:55:10) Great movie.
Jackson: (1:55:11) Even maybe There Will Be Blood or some of the PTA stuff, The Last Dance, or Wright Thompson's writing—The Cost of These Dreams. It's really about the cost of these dreams.
And interestingly, people in tech—especially Whiplash and The Social Network are the two best examples—I don't want to say they misinterpret the movie, but they take a very specific... I guess what I'm interested in is why you think The Social Network is not. I certainly don't think Aaron Sorkin was trying to make it into Mark Zuckerberg.
Anu: (1:55:43) He was trying to cast a negative light for sure, I think, on this.
Jackson: (1:55:46) I'm curious. I can probably answer at least in the case of Whiplash. I don't know if I have the same response to The Social Network. Maybe I was also just too much of a Steve Jobs kid or whatever.
Anu: (1:55:57) I think Whiplash is—I actually think obsession is—it is about ambition, but I think Whiplash is actually slightly more about obsession.
Jackson: (1:56:04) Maybe that's why I connect with it more.
Anu: (1:56:05) And here's why I think. I think the craft in Whiplash is more of an art.
Jackson: (1:56:11) Yeah.
Anu: (1:56:11) And I think the craft in The Social Network is more of a sport or the game of business, effectively, even though, yes, entrepreneurship is combining both elements.
Jackson: (1:56:21) Yeah. But I have a more powerful reaction to both the Michael Jordan stuff as well as Whiplash. Because the feeling I get is like, yes, obviously this is so bad, but oh, what it might be to be great.
Anu: (1:56:36) With Whiplash?
Jackson: (1:56:38) With both. With Michael Jordan or Whiplash.
Anu: (1:56:40) Sure.
Jackson: (1:56:41) And—
Anu: (1:56:41) You don't get that feeling?
Jackson: (1:56:42) No. But anyway, I'm monologuing, but I'm curious why you think this movie has become such a... the amount of founders who are like, "I watched The Social Network and I want it to be that."
Anu: (1:56:56) I think, on your comment, the reason I think that you think Whiplash and the Michael Jordan stuff is more about greatness is because it's like a singular person pursuing a singular craft that is somewhat easily definable as greatness. And I think this other angle is like a business game.
Jackson: (1:57:18) I also think, frankly, both—maybe I'm projecting here my thoughts on Zuck broadly—but it's more about war. It's about building the biggest empire and winning the biggest war.
Anu: (1:57:29) Yeah, I think it's something about the word ambition. I love Whiplash; it's a great movie as well. The ending scene is phenomenal, of course, but I think I view it a little bit less about ambition and more about something about greatness.
Jackson: (1:57:43) Maybe a different question: Why do you think the cautionary tale that Fincher and Sorkin—presumably especially Sorkin—was trying to say didn't resonate and instead inverted into this other thing? Is it just because it put ambition on display and ambition is attractive to that type of person?
Anu: (1:57:57) I'm sure there's a theoretical answer here, but I think a significant part of it is actually just the setting as well. It's in college.
Jackson: (1:58:10) It's like what it's actually like or theoretically what it's like, right?
Anu: (1:58:12) Yeah. And that whole environment is actually very appealing. It's very meta in that way, whereas he's like, "Oh, I'm at Harvard and I want to get into the Finals Clubs at Harvard."
A lot of college or teenage coming-of-age type movies are very resonant with young audiences, even if the message isn't extremely positive, in my opinion. So I think this element of this movie is the reason that he wasn't able to make it an extremely cautionary tale.
And by the way, also, Facebook is extremely successful and a lot of people use it. It's not like it got shut down. Who's not interested in a young person that's just like them becoming the new king of the technological revolution? And by the way, we all use this product and like it at the time.
Jackson: (1:59:02) Well, yeah, but I mean, there's one whole separate theory of tech culture which is just the Zuck pendulum, which is every three or four years it goes from love to hate.
Anu: (1:59:08) That's probably true. I'm sure I'll come up with more reasons later, but I think it's very hard to make a coming-of-age story not resonate with people who are coming of age. And if you show that person being very successful, it's that much harder.
Jackson: (1:59:24) You say everyone just wants to make a movie. What kind of movie do you want to make?
Anu: (1:59:28) So I have two genres of movies that are my favorite. This one is what I call a conversational film, which is of no surprise, which we should talk about another movie which I think you like as well.
Jackson: (1:59:38) I do.
Anu: (1:59:39) And then my second genre that I like a lot is the psychological thriller, but I use that somewhat loosely—less in the full horror genre, but like Inception, Gone Girl, Shutter Island.
These types of films where you're really in the mind—it's really about the mind, even though there's a lot of other things going on. So I think they're just different genres, but fundamentally I think my interest across them is the same. It's just about people.
Jackson: (2:00:10) Martin Scorsese, via Bong Joon-ho, says the most personal is the most creative.
Anu: (2:00:13) Yes.
2:00:16 Great Conversation & Before Sunrise
Jackson: (2:00:16) You referenced one of my favorite films, although not my favorite even of the trilogy, in your review.
Anu: (2:00:22) Is it the second?
Jackson: (2:00:24) Yeah, my favorite is Before Sunset.
Anu: (2:00:25) Yes, that is the better film, but it just can't exist without this film.
Jackson: (2:00:29) This is true. You say, "What a lovely thing to say. I love it for its near singular focus on great conversation. The most exhilarating thing in life and so rare." Why does it need to be rare? Why is it rare?
Anu: (2:00:49) I think it's rare that you would have something to the level of exhilarating conversation with many people. I don't think it's rare in how many exhilarating conversations you can have.
Jackson: (2:01:02) Ah.
Anu: (2:01:04) I'm open to the idea, of course, that you can work on the exhilarating-ness of conversations, but I do think that there's something a little bit like... It's like, do you believe there's one soulmate? Do you believe there's ten soulmates? What do you believe? And I think that same thing extends to conversational impact.
Jackson: (2:01:30) Yeah, yeah.
Anu: (2:01:31) What do you think?
Jackson: (2:01:34) I think what I aspire to believe is that the bar can be raised across all the conversations. So one implication here is that the only way to have exhilarating conversation is to have this kind of magical chemistry or something.
And that's probably true. It's sort of like, how much innate talent is there in this chemistry?
Anu: (2:01:55) Yeah. But you can also, you know, take the doorknobs.
Jackson: (2:01:59) Exactly. I just interviewed Adam Mastroianni. I think it's a bit like agency, maybe, which sounds weird, but I think that the bar...
Yes, most people aren't Elon, but also we can't simply accept that most people aren't agentic at all. And I think similarly, I want to be greedy with this. It's one of the few parts of life where I want to be totally gluttonous and always be hunting.
Anu: (2:02:26) This seems like the right thing to be doing.
Jackson: (2:02:31) Well, I realized I was telling people my favorite movie is Before Sunset, which is the second in this trilogy, and it's an 80-minute conversation. I realized it's basically a podcast, so here we are. You ever seen My Dinner with Andre?
Anu: (2:02:42) Yeah.
Jackson: (2:02:42) Another great podcast movie.
Anu: (2:02:43) What did you think about the third one? It's a hot topic.
Jackson: (2:02:46) I've actually started—I recommend these a lot, and I've started hedging and saying, "Definitely watch the first two."
I think the third one is more of a—like when you're ready and prepared.
Anu: (2:03:01) The first time I watched it, I disowned it. I was like, "There's only two." But then I went and rewatched it, and I had a much better appreciation.
Jackson: (2:03:07) It has—my favorite scene—is it a dinner scene? Exactly. We're three hours into this podcast, but the dinner scene, I think, is the best scene in any of the movies.
Anu: (2:03:16) That's what redeemed the movie for me.
Jackson: (2:03:18) Yeah, there's an old woman whose husband's passed away, and she sees his face in the clouds sometimes.
She says it's something along the lines of—we think we're so, to use your language, heavy, so weighty, but really, like a sunrise or a sunset or anything so ephemeral, we're just passing through.
Anu: (2:03:44) Great movie. That would be hard to make with that premise in the modern day.
Jackson: (2:03:48) Oh my gosh. But an amazing premise. Yes. An amazing premise that literally doesn't work with phones.
Anu: (2:03:53) Amazing premise. Yeah.
Jackson: (2:03:54) What's your favorite film?
Anu: (2:03:57) I can't pick favorites. I can only pick genres, I feel like.
Certainly Before—I mean, I do think Before Sunset is a better film, but I think Before Sunrise is the first one, so I kind of feel like I have to—
Jackson: (2:04:09) Get people in.
Anu: (2:04:11) I have to call it because it's the premise, right?
Jackson: (2:04:17) But the second one is as much the premise, which is like—we're going to run it back.
There was no sequel planned.
Anu: (2:04:25) The last scene—the last line of the movie—is...
Jackson: (2:04:28) Best ending of a movie ever made.
Anu: (2:04:29) Yeah. It's hard for me to rank a lot of other ones, to be honest. I think this is a way throwback, but Home Alone is one of my favorite movies. That's in my childhood category, so that's a separate category.
Jackson: (2:04:40) We'll do a Letterboxd top four. We got Home Alone. We got Before Sunrise.
Anu: (2:04:44) I probably would pick The Social Network, even though I just think it's a perfect film. I don't even know if it's the most resonant.
Yeah, we didn't even talk about this, but the score—I think similarly, it's the same folks who did the score for Gone Girl. I think that's a big part of my love for those movies as well.
I think soundtracks and scores are very underrated in why films are good. So I probably would have to include that.
What's a fourth? It's either got to be—honestly, I like a lot of Nolan movies. I think probably Inception is my favorite one because it's very layered. It's like the meta, or the anti-meta of the anti-meta of the anti-meta.
Jackson: (2:05:39) Great premise.
Anu: (2:05:39) A great premise. Absolutely.
Jackson: (2:05:41) Movies really are the testing ground for premises.
Anu: (2:05:43) They are. I also do like something like When Harry Met Sally.
Jackson: (2:05:50) Banger.
Anu: (2:05:50) But I think I've rewatched it enough times where it's lost a little bit.
Jackson: (2:05:56) Yeah, but then you get fall in New York and you're like, feel it. It's in the air. Great.
Anu: (2:05:59) But yeah, besides the childhood movie, which has to be in there. Conversational and psychological drama, that's kind of it. What about you? You have to give me your—
Jackson: (2:06:10) My current Letterboxd top four are Before Sunset, Annie Hall...
Anu: (2:06:17) Good movie.
Jackson: (2:06:19) Except for art, artist, whatever. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
Anu: (2:06:25) Great premise.
Jackson: (2:06:25) Great premise. And Arrival.
Anu: (2:06:29) I didn't love that movie.
Jackson: (2:06:31) It's controversial. It builds with time. I feel strongly about rewatching films.
Why do you love Animal Farm?
Anu: (2:06:38) Well, it's like a parable about people and how people are, told in an obviously creative way, almost such that it would not make us realize it's about us until it's about us.
I just think satire in general is very underdone. I just think that we don't do enough intellectual satire anymore about what's going on.
The closest thing we have to intellectual satire now is something like The Daily Show or maybe some comedians like Dave Chappelle. Nathan Fielder—he's a great example. That's a great new example of this type of genre.
Jackson: (2:07:12) It is rare. It's an example, but it's very rare.
Anu: (2:07:14) Very rare. And I just do think it was more popular in the era of writers of satire.
I really like this line: "All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." It's such an aesthetically elegant way to make the point.
So I don't know, just the way it's written—the parable about classic themes about people, like power, ambition, all of these sorts of things that are revealed.
Jackson: (2:07:49) Why do you love Survivor?
Anu: (2:07:52) Human nature. That's the easiest. It's the best reality TV show, even though I do like other reality TV shows. It's just human nature. Put people together—it's a perfect reality TV show.
I don't know what to say. I could get more intellectual. It has a lot of life lessons as well that are—there's one that's very resonant with Silicon Valley, which I always talk about: in Survivor, you're on tribes and you're competing, and somebody gets immunity every week.
You never really know who's going to be in power the next day. So you have to constantly be making alliances, making choices, and then adapting.
Jackson: (2:08:33) You can't trust the hierarchy to persist.
Anu: (2:08:35) Correct, which is—but by nature, when the hierarchy comes about, people react a certain way. We're very used to obeying those hierarchies as well.
So I feel like the relevance to Silicon Valley is just that you never know who's going to be the next hot founder tomorrow or the next successful person.
Jackson: (2:08:56) Or make fun of AI researchers or AI bots.
Anu: (2:08:58) Exactly.
2:08:58 Walk Through the Door
Jackson: (2:09:01) To you, the most entertaining outcome is the most likely outcome because it's often the most energizing one.
Anu: (2:09:09) I think that's true.
Jackson: (2:09:11) Why the distinction "the most energizing one"? What does it mean for an outcome to be the most energizing?
Anu: (2:09:16) It's like TBPN selling to OpenAI. Even if you could argue what is the logic of doing this, I would be like, one of the things that trumps all logic is that it's definitely the most energizing thing to be like, "Okay, we've been on this journey for a couple of years. What is our energy going to be like if we just stay on this exact journey?"
And I kind of have this framework or idea that I think media-ish businesses or products or properties have a two-to-three-year cycle of interestingness in their continued trajectory. And then something needs to happen.
Jackson: (2:09:56) Yes, you need a new season.
Anu: (2:09:57) You need a new season, you need a second act. You need something. And in this case, otherwise your energy drops off as well, right? Not even necessarily the success, but I think the energy itself goes away.
And so I'm like, well, let's have this big next step which is selling to OpenAI. Yes, it's logical economically and many other things, but yeah, it's kind of like, okay, we're on this new arc of a story now.
Jackson: (2:10:19) A tweet from you: "My working theory is that creative people already have the idea for their life's work years before they find the right form factor to express it." Do you have a sense of what the form factor is for you?
Anu: (2:10:35) It probably involves writing, but what is the form? I mean, what is my life's work? I don't know if I know for sure because I think it's going to be a series of creations.
I'm in the "what is a life's work" phase, but which of the creations is it going to be? I'm not exactly sure. Each creation might have a slightly different form factor, which is why I'm not sure about that. But I think it'll include writing.
Jackson: (2:11:08) My last thing, a quote from Jim Carrey: "As far as I can tell, it's just about letting the universe know what you want and working toward it while letting go of how it comes to pass. Your job is not to figure out how it's going to happen for you, but to open the door in your head. And when the door opens in real life, just walk through it."
Nothing too new based on what we've been talking about, but why that quote? Why is it resonant?
Anu: (2:11:44) I think everybody who's chasing something thinks that getting that thing is going to be extremely—
Jackson: (2:11:55) I cut off part of the quote, but that's what was at the beginning.
Anu: (2:11:56) Yeah. And I think the part you talked about is letting go of the outcome of something and therefore doing the thing because you're interested in doing the thing.
But I think the reason he was saying that is because it feels like you're going to suddenly get money, fame, power, wealth, and then suddenly that'll solve all your problems, but it never actually does. So you should just therefore focus on the thing that you want to be doing and let go of all the things that it's going to get you.
I think it's challenging because it's always hard to hear it from somebody who you perceive has gotten the things. I think that's one of these meta-challenging things about wisdom, but it feels very true nonetheless.
Jackson: (2:12:33) Something about him, though, I think makes it feel a little more true.
Anu: (2:12:36) Yeah, his collection of things that he does, his artistry. I think it's resonant also just because it's a reminder to myself. I mean, I think we all chase a lot of these things, right? It's hard to fully divorce yourself from something you're trying to do and the grand outcomes that it could be.
There's this David Foster Wallace quote where somebody asked him, "Why do you care so much about respect? You seem to care about respect." And his offhand comment was, "Show me somebody who doesn't care about respect." Which I think is very true. It's very easy to get sucked up in all these things.
But then also he says, "Yeah, I mean, I got successful very early with my writing. And then I was like, 'Oh, okay, now I'm having a midlife crisis,' even though it's not midlife, because what's the brass ring that I have to keep chasing? I don't know what that brass ring is anymore."
So I think the chase keeps people actually sane, but then realizing that the thing you're chasing isn't going to be the answer throws you into its own little insanity. And that's kind of like the circle of life.
Jackson: (2:13:38) One of the reasons I love that ending to that quote from Jim is he's talking about, "Don't chase the thing. And when the door opens in real life, just walk through it." Yeah, let the world, let the universe conspire for you too. And we flip those two energies; we get them mixed.
Anu: (2:13:52) Yeah, you know what that goes to? I remember a long time ago, we had coffee and you were telling me about how you don't believe in trying to hack willpower.
Jackson: (2:13:59) Ah, yes. This is one of my controversial views.
Anu: (2:14:03) I don't think it's controversial. I think it's actually related to that. Hacking willpower is trying to find the doors that aren't open for you.
Jackson: (2:14:10) Right. When the door is there, all you've got to do is walk through it. But you need to walk through it.
Thank you. This was great.
Anu: (2:14:20) Thank you.
Jackson: (2:14:20) Thank you to our listeners for bearing with 20 minutes of Before Sunrise conversation.